Monday, November 16, 2026

The Single Vocation And The Marriage Vocation

 


To My Readers: This week TradWarrior writes about the joys and difficulties of the married state and the single state of life. Very informative! Please feel free to comment as always. If anyone has a specific question or comment for me, I will answer as usual, but it may take me a bit longer to respond this week.

God bless you all, my dear readers---Introibo

The Single Vocation and the Marriage Vocation
By TradWarrior

I have received many requests from various readers of this blog, both younger and older, to write a post on the single vocation, as well as on courtship/dating. In this article, I examine the blessings and the difficulties that a person faces whether they choose the single vocation or the marriage vocation. There are several points that I have taken (with Introibo’s permission) from two of his articles – “The Single-Minded Devotion” and “Choosing A Marriage Partner In Today’s World.” This article will be less theological in nature compared to many of the other posts that I have written. I wanted this article to be far more pastoral than theological and very easy to understand for anyone who reads it, particularly our young readers. It is my sincere hope that this post helps many readers out there. ---TradWarrior 

Living in today’s world is not easy. There are constant pressures that we are constantly bombarded by and attacks that hit us spiritually from every side. It is vitally important to cultivate a strong prayer life to navigate us through the rough waters that we must wade through. Some of us will face these challenges alone throughout our lives if we should remain single over the course of our lives, while others will have a partner to help them over the course of his or her life. Whatever vocation that one chooses, it is important to choose that vocation for the right reasons. 

The Single Vocation 

For those of us who choose to remain single over the course of our lives, it can be a very rewarding vocation. The single state is superior to the married state. Being single allows an individual to spend far more time in prayer, growing closer and closer to God. Generally, there are fewer distractions in the single state that allows an individual to focus more on God and to improve himself or herself as best he or she can.

The single vocation is the often forgotten about vocation. Marriage, priesthood, and religious life are vocations that have always been talked about throughout the Catholic Church’s history. The single vocation is often thrown more to the background, with much less being said about it. Many people who opt to stay single over the course of their lives often feel forgotten or not as important. They often times get glossed over for one reason or another.

In Introibo’s article entitled “Single-Minded Devotion,” published December 21, 2020, he mentions several joys and sorrows of the single vocation. They are so good that they deserve to be reproduced here in their entirety: 

The single person:

·     Can spend more time in prayer and in meditation of the things of God


·      Can place himself/herself at the service of others and bring them to Christ


·       Is an amazing witness to the beauty of Christian ideals by putting the Kingdom of           God before all else, having no earthly duties to family


·       Has less pressure to work overtime and earn more


·        Can develop more interests/talents and deep friendships that are like family


·        Can be more health conscious and take better care of their bodily condition


·         Becomes highly self-sufficient


·        Can change careers/jobs with much greater ease and retire earlier

 

The challenges of the single life include:

 

·       The older the person gets, more of their friends will be married, and they will have    less time to enjoy their company. Going out with their family often makes the single person feel like a "third wheel"--but they can become everyone's favorite "aunt" or "uncle"


·      People will constantly try to set them up on dates or ask them why they don't get married. Do not expect a non-Traditionalist to understand the single vocation


·     They will many times be calumniated as being a sodomite or having "something wrong" with them


·     They come home to an empty house/apartment and can feel lonely at times


·     They need people to check on them if living alone in case of an accident or emergency


·      They will not beget physical children, but will have "spiritual children" from conversions and/or spiritual good works performed to the benefit and salvation of others 


·      They do not have a partner with whom to do things many times

 

Introibo’s list of the pros and cons to the single vocation is excellent and not much more needs to be said here. 

The Marriage Vocation 

In Introibo’s article entitled “Choosing A Marriage Partner In Today’s World,” published May 15, 2023, Introibo lists a number of bullet points that one must ask themselves if these are the reasons they think they need to get married. These are not good reasons, yet nevertheless, many people get married because of these various reasons. As Introibo noted, they include:

 

·      All (or almost all) of my friends/family are married, so I should get married too


·      My parents want me to get married


·       I don't like being alone


·      People will think I'm strange or a sodomite if I don't get married by a certain age


·      A woman's "biological clock is ticking" and she decides she would like to have a child, so marry someone


·      You are afraid your boyfriend or girlfriend will leave you and you won't find anyone else, so marry them


·      You want to experience sex without sinning

In addition, there are several character traits that you should not possess if you want to enter the married state in life. 

Do not seek marriage if: 

1. You are self-centered and not willing to enter a vocation where sacrifices for your spouse and children are frequently necessary. 

2. You are easily offended and hold grudges. This attitude will take a terrible toll on your spouse, your children, and you.  

3. Your career comes first, and you will place advancement in that career ahead of your spouse and children. 

4. You have an unresolved serious vice, such as porn addiction, drinking too much, using recreational drugs, or gambling.  

Your primary motivation for getting married should be to procreate and grow the Body of Christ on Earth, and to help your spouse and children reach Heaven. 

Introibo goes on to mention moral qualifications and agreement areas where a person should focus on and ask himself/herself. For a list of these points, one can view them at his article. 

Towards the end of his article, he mentions four lessons that he has often reiterated from time to time. They include the following: 

Lesson 1: Go for 100% of what you want, don't settle, and keep your eyes open at all times 

Lesson 2: You can find someone who has everything right, but is still not right for YOU. There may be insurmountable personality conflicts. 

Lesson 3: Discuss what's important early in the relationship. If they don't give an enthusiastic answer you want, end it.  Otherwise, you waste your time. 

Lesson 4 (most important): Never date anyone in the Vatican II sect unless they don't practice, and never get involved with anyone who is not genuinely open to Traditionalist Catholicism and conversion.  

In having reiterated several of Introibo’s points, I would like to dive a bit deeper into the single and marriage vocation. 

Connecting with people is getting harder and harder in today’s world. People are connected and dialed in with technology everywhere, yet communication is still incredibly lacking in so many areas. How many times have you gone to a restaurant and seen a father, mother, son, and daughter all texting on their phones and no one raising their head to communicate with each other? How many times have you also gone to a restaurant and seen a couple on a date doing the same thing, never looking up from their mobile devices? 

Human beings are social creatures. God made us this way. The digital age has made face to face communication less stressed today, as texts, emails, instant messages, and other forms of modern communication have taken over. Even on blogs such as this one, how many disagreements have arisen by different commenters because one person emphasized a word or two and the other person thought that they were being condescending or cruel when that may never have been the intent of the sender of the message? Like this blog, many people communicate with absolute strangers, people they will never meet face to face. 

For those who are seeking the single devotion, one has to enter into it for the right reasons. There is nothing wrong with being single in today’s world and more and more people are opting to stay single. When we look around the world today and how crazy it is, can anyone honestly blame someone for choosing to never marry? 

Young people are faced with an onslaught of issues that they face. These include smoking, drinking, drugs, premarital sex, secularism, modernism, relativism, naturalism, indifferentism, parental divorce, depression, suicide, and many other issues that make life almost unbearable in many respects. If a person is strongly considering marriage, they have to be ready to not only face the world and all that it throws at them by themselves, but this now expands to protecting their spouse and children from much of the garbage that the world will throw at them. The world, the flesh, and the devil never stop in their attacks. It is hard enough going through life by oneself, but when a family is added to the mix, everything gets exponentially that much more difficult to walk the “straight and narrow” path.

 If a person feels called to the single state, there is nothing wrong with that. There are more single people today than ever before and this is because finding a suitable mate is getting harder and harder to find. Staying single can help a person grow much closer to God.  It allows one the freedom to grow in holiness in the Faith and to focus on oneself. There is a lot more free time that a single person has that allows him or her to serve God in a better capacity as well as it helps the person to grow and mature in his or her own way. They can spend more time in their job helping people as well as volunteer opportunities to help the community at large. These are very good things.

For those who feel called to marriage, that is also a beautiful state. The wedlock of a man and woman for life is a very special thing. You have a marriage partner who is there to help you and your children (if you are blessed with children) to get to Heaven. Partaking in God’s creative plan to bring new life into this world, so that these new lives have the capability of one day spending eternity in Heaven with God and the Communion of Saints is a marvelous thing! Cooperating with God’s plan to create an immortal soul is a very special and sacred event. 

A person that feels called to marriage must go into it though for the right reasons. The primary focus must be on God. The couple who get married must put the Faith first and their family right after that in order of importance. The husband needs to be able to provide for his family. He is the head of the home. The wife needs to be willing to raise the children in many of the day-to-day activities that come with the rearing of children. She is the heart of the home. Together, husband and wife must work as a team. 

Many young people today (whether traditional or secular) go into marriage thinking that it is a romance novel. They envision it like a prince sweeping the princess off of her feet and living happily ever after. They think their entire lifetime will mimic a 2-hour Hallmark movie, where boy meets girl, boy falls in love with girl, boy marries girl, and boy and girl live happily ever after. Nowhere in most of these stories do you see the wife’s mother dying of cancer, the husband’s father prolonged by a lingering dementia that slowly takes his mind and faculties, the death of their teen-age child killed by the drunk driver, etc. No, they are usually sunshine and roses-type stories. Real life is much different. There will be problems and difficulties along the way that never stop. Why, because we live in a fallen world. 

There is an overemphasis on sex in today’s world. In the marriage state, Eros love is very important. It helps the couple to bond. This expression of physical love is a very beautiful thing. What almost all couples today do not take into consideration why they are courting/dating someone (whether younger or older) is that Eros love MUST BE (emphasis added) superseded by Agape love. This type of love is the highest form of love and the perfect example of this is Christ’s love that He displayed while dying on the cross. 

The Son of God took on the entire sins of the world in His barbaric passion. The theologians of the Catholic Church knew that one drop of blood would have been sufficient and perfectly pleasing to God the Father to redeem mankind. It didn’t even have to be a drop of Christ’s blood. A simple good act by Jesus would have been infinitely pleasing to God the Father and sufficient to redeem the human race. But no, Christ chose to undergo a barbaric passion to atone for the horrendous sins that every human being that offended Him committed. His expiation that He made for mankind went to a depth that no angelic or human mind can fathom. For people considering marriage, especially young people, they need to first focus on Agape love. Eros love will inevitably follow. Ask yourself the difficult questions. 

If you REALLY love this person, will you stick with them through thick and thin? If your husband is paralyzed from the waist down, would you take care of him until he died (should he precede you in death)? After all, it is until “death do you part.” If your wife became blind, would you be her eyes and love her just the same if she never lost her sight? If your husband developed Alzheimer’s, would you care for him throughout his life? If your wife lost a limb, would you assist her in the things she would need additional help with, no longer having an arm or a leg anymore? If your child was severely mentally retarded or physically handicapped, would you say, “I didn’t sign up for this. I’m done with this marriage,” and leave your spouse to become a single parent overnight (which happens every single day), or would you stay by their side and endure the hardships that come with raising this child that you helped to bring into this world?

 These types of questions never get considered today by most couples and this is a real travesty. You must be willing to embrace the pain, just as much as the joy of a marriage. There will be many painful moments and again, we have to look to Christ on the cross. He had the power to come down from the cross as he said, yet He chose to continue to hang there, knowing man’s redemption was close at hand, due to His tremendous suffering. He didn’t say, “Okay, I have suffered for 15 minutes on this cross now. Father, I’m coming down. I have had enough!” No, He stayed there for 3 hours. We must be willing to endure tremendous suffering too if we feel called to the married state (or the single state), as every state of life will have different types of sufferings, but we have to take the pain with the pleasure, the joys with the sorrows, the humiliation with the glory. This is life and we cannot escape it.   

One problem that is more prevalent today is people are becoming so desperate to meet someone that they are settling for anyone, just for the sake of not being alone. This is extremely dangerous and these types of marriages will not last. If this is a person’s reason for seeking marriage, then it is better off if this person stayed single for life. What seems like a good thing now in finding someone to marry will eventually turn into a horrific situation after you say “I Do” and are now stuck with ending up with someone that is completely wrong for you. This happens every single day. A man meets a woman and wants to marry her because he feels he is getting older and he needs to get married. He marries her and regrets it right after the wedding. A few years go by and he meets the woman that is perfect for him. It’s too late! He already vowed to be with the first woman for life, even though he is not happy, and is now in a perpetual state of misery. 

A person must be extremely careful when they commit to someone in marriage as it is for life and only death breaks the sacramental bond of matrimony. Under certain circumstances, a person can seek a separation or a civil divorce, but they are still validly married to that spouse and in this time of “sede vacante,” there is no pope to appeal to in order to see if an annulment (even for valid reasons) would be feasible. If you marry, you better marry well. People do change over time, but the crux of the married couples' lives must be centered around the Faith. 

One of the big issues that Introibo referenced is the issue of the biological clock ticking. Many females today fall into despair when they hit a certain age and they panic and feel like their life is ending if they are not married by 30, 35, 40, etc. If you have not met your ideal match by any age, it is better to stay single and live your life content in who you are, not who you think you would be if you were with this or that person right now because you have to have someone in your life at this very moment. People that rush into marriage for this reason are doomed to failure in many cases. 

God wants us to be happy. He loves each and every one of us more than we could possibly fathom and as His children, He wants us to find the vocation that we were meant to choose. This takes prayer and discernment. While the single state is superior to the married state, both states are beautiful because both states were created by God. If we cooperate with His grace, we can experience bountiful blessings in the vocation that He willed for us. Yes, we have free will and can choose to accept or reject a vocation, but the vocation that He wants for us and that we will come to realize (if we follow His will as prayerfully as possible) will bring us the greatest amount of joy in this life. 

It is always ideal to marry a traditional Catholic. This is not always easy in today’s world. In some cases it is not even possible for someone who has no traditional Catholics anywhere in their general vicinity. Courting/dating and marrying a traditional Catholic gives a person the greatest amount of hope that the marriage will last. This does not mean that if you marry a traditional Catholic that you will not have problems along your journey or even that the marriage is guaranteed to last, for some traditional marriages fail too. But it allows you the greatest chance of success for the couples focus in usually on the most important things that matter and not trivial matters that most of the secular culture focuses on. 

One of the biggest problems among traditional Catholics is that there are not many of them! The pool of people in the Novus Ordo is much, much larger. Should a traditional Catholic date a Novus Ordo? This is a very good question and one that Introibo answered in his above statement. You should only date a Novus Ordo if they do not practice or they are open to conversion to the traditional Faith. A Novus Ordo that doesn’t practice the faith will be more open to converting to traditional Catholicism than a practicing Novus Ordo because a practicing Novus Ordo is already strongly under the impression that they belong to the Catholic Church and a Sedevacantist must be wrong, especially when one makes the claim that there has been no valid pope since 1958. This statement alone will have people running away from you very quickly. 

This situation has to be handled prudently. For the Novus Ordo who is open to conversion, the situation is still dicey, but if they are sincere and truly open to wanting to follow the Truth at all costs and they are willing to humbly submit to the Truth wherever it is found, then this does present a chance of success and in this case, there could be many more potential dating partners, since the pool of people in the Novus Ordo is much larger. The majority of people will still have to be ruled out, as they are not going to be that serious at finding the True Faith. Again, they believe they already have it in many respects, so if someone comes along claiming that they have been wrong all these years but they can be shown the Truth, most Novus Ordo’s are going to dismiss that person flat out. Not all will, and if the person really likes you, there is a chance for success. The ideal situation is to always marry a traditional Catholic. Decades ago, this was never a problem. 

Today, there are so few traditional Catholics compared to the Novus Ordo, that it is very hard to find a possible mate among traditionalists. There are also a lot of strange traditionalists out there and in some cases, it is better to date a secular person over a traditionalist or a Novus Ordo, IF (emphasis added) the secular is truly open to the Truth. Working with a blank slate is sometimes easier. Unfortunately, there are no easy answers when entering into the courting/dating arena. 

There are many problems that a person faces today, and many go beyond the issue of are you both members of the same religion. Many other issues come up and will have to be dealt with such as job issues (will you need a dual income to survive, as most people do today), how open to children is your potential spouse, do you like your potential mate’s family and could you see yourself married to this person if you love him/her but you cannot stand their family, etc. Many times, the important questions are not asked quickly enough as people go through a euphoric state of infatuation and not looking beyond the surface. The deeper questions and issues need to be focused on fairly quickly. You need to scout out this person to see if they would make a good spouse, a good parent to your future children, a good provider for the husband, a good house maintainer for the wife (even if she has to work in the world due to money issues which are common today), etc.

Conclusion

There are many challenges and difficulties that people, especially young people are faced with today when choosing a vocation. For those who truly feel called to the single life, do not let anyone or anything detract you. You can grow closer to God, focus on yourself, your job, volunteer opportunities, and other things that will help you grow spiritually as a person. If you feel called to the married state, do not let fear drive you away. Like the single state, put God first, but then put your spouse and children (if you are blessed to have children) right after God and be willing to sacrifice for your family in all that you do, so that you can one day get not only yourself to Heaven, but those under your care as well. 

God created the single and marriage vocations. Each person’s path in life is unique and different. There are many people who would not do well going through life in the single state and there are many people who would not make a good spouse or parent in the married state. Whichever path you feel God is calling you to (and some are called to priesthood or religious life), do everything in your power to pursue the vocation that God has asked you to follow. “For I know the plans I have for you,” declares the Lord, “plans to prosper you and not to harm you, plans to give you hope and a future.” (Jer. 29:11) Do not think that you are any less important than anyone else or that God does not truly care about what vocation you choose or the decisions that you make in life. He loves you dearly and cares about all that you do. As our Lord said in reference to how we should not worry excessively, just as the birds do not worry about what they will eat from day to day, “So don’t be afraid; you are worth more than many sparrows.” (St. Matthew 10:31).

Monday, November 9, 2026

The Eucharist And The Obligation Of Receiving Holy Communion

 


To My Readers: This week's guest poster, John Gregory, writes about important truths pertaining to the Most Holy Eucharist. We can never ponder enough the truths about the Blessed Sacrament. Please feel free to comment as per usual. If anyone has a specific question or comment for me, I will respond as always, but it may take me a bit longer to do so this week.

God bless you all, my dear readers---Introibo

The Form, Matter, and Rites of the Holy Eucharist, and The Obligation Of Receiving Holy Communion

By John Gregory

Constituent Parts of the Eucharist 

THE MATTER 

It is particularly incumbent on pastors to know the matter of this Sacrament, in order that they themselves may rightly consecrate it, and also that they may be able to instruct the faithful as to its significance, inflaming them with an earnest desire of that which it signifies. 

THE FIRST ELEMENT OF THE EUCHARIST IS BREAD 

The matter of this Sacrament is twofold.  The first element of wheaten bread, of which we shall now speak.  Of the second we shall treat hereafter.  As the Evangelists, Mathew, Mark and Luke testify, Christ the Lord took bread into His hands, blessed, and brake, saying: This is my body; (Matthew 26: 26; Mark 14: 22; Luke 22: 19) and, according to John, the same Saviour called Himself bread in these words: I am the living bread, that came down from heaven. (John 6: 41). 

THE SACRAMENTAL BREAD MUST BE WHEATEN 

Theare are, however, various sorts of bread, either because they consist of different materials,—such as wheat, barley, pulse and other products of the earth; or because they posses different qualities,—some being leavened, others altogether without leaven.  It is to be observed that, with regard to the former kinds, the words of the Saviour show that the bread should be wheaten; for, according to common usage, when we simply say bread, we are sufficiently understood to mean wheaten bread.  This is also declared by a figure in the Old Testament, because the Lord commanded that the loaves of proposition which signified this Sacrament, should be made of fine flour. (Leviticus 24: 5) 

THE SACRAMENTAL BREAD SHOULD BE UNLEAVENED 

But as wheaten bread alone is to be considered the proper matter for this Sacrament—a doctrine which has been handed down by Apostolic tradition and confirmed by the authority of the Catholic Church—it may be easily inferred from the doings of Christ the Lord that this bread should be unleavened.  It was consecrated and instituted by Him on the first day of unleavened bread, on which it was not lawful for the Jews to have anything leavened in their houses. (Matthew 27: 17; Mark 14: 12; Luke 22: 7) 

Should the authority of John the Evangelist, (John 13: 1) who says that all this was done before the feast of the Passover, be objected to, the argument is one of easy solution.  For by the day before the pasch John understands the same day which the other Evangelists designate as the first day of unleavened bread. He wished particularly to mark the natural day, which commences at sunrise; whereas they wanted to point out that our Lord celebrated the Pach on Thursday evening just when the days of the unleavened bread were beginning.  Hence Saint Chrysostom also understands the first day of unleavened bread to be the day on the evening of which unleavened bread was to be eaten. [For an explanation of the time when our Lord kept His last Pasch and instituted the Holy Eucharist see Callan, The four Gospels, pages 167-171.] 

The peculiar suitableness of the consecration of unleavened bread to express that integrity and purity of mind which the faithful should bring to this Sacrament we learn from these words of the Apostle: Purge out the old leaven that you may be a new paste, as you are unleavened.   For Christ our Passover is sacrificed.  Therefore, let us feast, not with the old leaven, nor with the leaven of malice and wickedness, but with the unleavened bread of sincerity and truth. (1 Corinthians 5: 7) 

UNLEAVENED BREAD NOT ESSENTIAL 

This quality of the bread, however, is not to be deemed so essential that, if it be wanting, the Sacrament cannot exist; for both kinds are called by the one name and have the true and proper nature of bread.  No one, however, is at liberty on his own private authority, or rather presumption, to transgress the laudable rite of his Church.  And such departure is the less warrantable in priests of the Latin Church, expressly obliged as they are by the supreme Pontiffs, to consecrate the sacred mysteries with unleavened bread only. 

QUANITY OF THE BREAD 

With regard to the first matter of this Sacrament, let this exposition suffice.  It is, however, to be observed, that the quantity of the matter to be consecrated is not defined, since we cannot define the exact number of those who can or ought to receive the sacred mysteries. 

THE SECOND ELEMENT OF THE EUCHARIST IS WINE 

It remains for us to treat of the other matter and element of this Sacrament, which is wine pressed from the fruit of the vine, with which is mingled a little water. 

That in the institution of this Sacrament our Lord and Saviour made use of wine has been at all times the doctrine of the Catholic Church, for He Himself said: I will not drink from henceforth of this fruit of the vine until that day. (Matthew 26: 29; Mark 14: 25) On this passage Chrysostom observes: He says, "Of the fruit of the vine," which certainly produced wine not water; as if he had it in view, even at so early a period, to uproot the heresy which asserted that in these mysteries water alone is to be used. 

WATER SHOULD BE MIXED WITH THE WINE 

With the wine, however, the Church of God has always mingled water.  First, because Christ the Lord did so, as is proved by the authority of Councils and the testimony of Saint Cyprian; next, because by this mixture is renewed the recollection of the blood and water that issued from His side, Walters, also, as we read in the Apocalypse, (Apocalypse 17: 15) signify the people; and hence, water mixed with the wine signifies the union of the faithful with Christ their Head.  This rite, derived as it is from Apostolic tradition, the Catholic Church has always observed.

 But although there are reasons so grave for mingling water with the wine that it cannot be omitted without incurring the guilt of mortal sin, yet its omission does not render the Sacrament null. 

Again as in the sacred mysteries priests must be mindful to mingle water with wine, so, also, must they take care to mingle it in small quantity, for, in the opinion and judgment of the ecclesiastical writers, that water is changed into wine.  Hence these words of Pope Honorius on the subject: A pernicious abuse has prevailed in your district of using in the sacrifice a greater quantity of water than of wine; whereas, according to the rational practice of the universal Church, the wine should be used in much greater quantity than the water. 

NO OTHER ELEMENTS PERTAIN TO THIS SACRAMENT 

These, then, are the only two elements of this Sacrament; and with reason has it been enacted by many decrees that, although there have been those who were not afraid to do so, it is unlawful to offer anything but bread and wine. 

PECULIAR FITNESS OF BREAD AND WINE 

We have now to consider the aptitude of these two symbols of bread and wine to represent those things of which we believe and confess they are the sensible signs. 

In the first place, then, they signify to us Christ, as the true life of men; for our Lord Himself says: My flesh is meat indeed, and my blood is drink indeed.  (John 6: 55) As, then, the body of Christ the Lord furnishes nourishment unto eternal life to those who receive this Sacrament with purity and holiness, rightly is the matter composed chiefly of those elements by which our present life is sustained, in order that the faithful may easily understand that the mind and soul are satiated by the Communion of the precious body and blood of Christ.  

These very elements serve also somewhat to suggest to men the truth of the Real Presence of the body and blood of the Lord in the Sacrament.  Observing, as we do, that bread and wine are every day changed by the power of nature into human flesh and blood, we are led the more easily by this analogy to believe that the substance of the bread and wine is changed, by the heavenly benediction, into the real flesh and real blood of Christ. 

This admirable change of the elements also helps to shadow forth what takes place in the soul.  Although no change of the bread and wine appears externally, yet their substance is truly changed into the flesh and blood of Christ; so, in like manner, although in us nothing appears changed, yet we are renewed inwardly unto life, when we receive in the Sacrament of the Eucharist the true life. 

Moreover, the body of the Church, which is one, consists of many members, and of this union nothing is more strikingly illustrative than the elements of bread and wine; for bread is made from many grains and wine is pressed from many clusters of grapes.  Thus they signify that we, though many, are most closely bound together by the bond of this divine mystery and made, as it were, one body. 

Form of the Eucharist 

 The form to be used in the consecration of the bread is next to be treated of, not, however, in order that the faithful should be taught these mysteries, unless necessity require it; for this knowledge is not needful for those who have not received Holy Orders.  The purpose (of this section) is to guard against most shameful mistakes on the part of priests, at the time of the consecration, due to ignorance of the form. 

FORM TO BE USED IN THE CONSECRATION OF THE BREAD 

We are then taught by the holy Evangelists, Matthew and Luke, and also by the Apostle, that the form consists of these words: This is my body; for it is written: Whilst they were at supper, Jesus took bread, and blessed it, and brake, and gave to his disciples, and said: Take and eat, This is my body. (Matthew 26: 26; Mark 14: 22; Luke 22: 19; 1 Corinthians 11: 24) This form of consecration having been observed by Christ the Lord has been always used by the Catholic Church.  The testimonies of the Fathers, the enumeration of which would be endless, and also the decree of the Council of Florence, which is well known and accessible to all, must here be omitted, especially as the knowledge which they convey may be obtained from these words of the Saviour: Do this for a commemoration of me. (Luke 22: 19) For what the Lord enjoined was not only what He had done, but also what he had said; and especially is this true, since the words were uttered not only to signify, but also to accomplish. 

That these words constitute the form is easily proved from reason also.  The form is that which signifies what is accomplished in this Sacrament; but as the preceding words signify and declare what takes place in the Eucharist, that is, the conversion of the bread into the true body of our Lord, it therefore follows that these very words constitute the form.  In this sense may be understood the words of the Evangelist: He blessed; for they seem equivalent to this: Taking bread, he blessed it, saying: "This is my body." (Matthew 26: 26) 

NOT ALL THE WORDS USED ARE ESSENTIAL 

Although in the Evangelist the words, Take and eat, precede the words (This is my body), they evidently express the use only, not the consecration, of the matter.  Wherefore, while they are not necessary to the consecration of the Sacrament, they are by all means to be pronounced by the priest, as is also the conjunction for in the consecration of the body and blood.  But they are not necessary to the validity of the Sacrament, otherwise it would follow that, if this Sacrament were not to be administered to anyone, it should not, or indeed could not, be consecrated; whereas, no one can lawfully doubt that the priest, by pronouncing the words of our Lord according to the institution and practice of the Church, truly consecrates the proper matter of the bread, even though it should afterwards never be administered. 

FORM TO BE USED IN THE CONSECRATION OF THE WINE 

With regard to the consecration of the wine, which is the other element of this Sacrament, the priest, for the reason we have already assigned, ought of necessity to be well acquainted with, and well understand its form.  We are then firmly to believe that it consists in the following words: This is the chalice of my blood, of the new and eternal testament, the mystery of faith, which shall be shed for you and for many, to the remission of sins.  Of these words the greater part are taken from Scripture; but some have been preserved in the Church from Apostolic tradition 

Thus the words, this is the chalice, are found in Saint Luke and in the Apostle; (Luke 12: 20; 1 Corinthians 11: 25) but the words that immediately follow, of my blood, or my blood of the new testament, which shall be shed for you and for many to the remission of sins, are found partly in Saint Luke and Partly in Saint Matthew. (Luke 22: 20; Matthew 26: 28) But the words, eternal, and the mystery of faith, have been taught us by holy tradition, the interpreter and keeper of Catholic truth. 

Concerning this form no one can doubt, if he here also attend to what has been already said about the form used in the consecration of the bread.  The form to be used (in the consecration) of this element, evidently consists of those words which signify that the substance of the wine is changed into the blood of our Lord.  Since therefore, the words already cited clearly declare this, it is plain that no other words constitute the form. 

They moreover express certain admirable fruits of the blood shed in the Passion of our Lord, fruits which pertain in a most special manner to this Sacrament.  Of these, one is access to the eternal inheritance, which has come to us by right of the new and everlasting testament. Another is access to righteousness by the mystery of faith; for God hath set forth Jesus to be a propitiator through faith in his blood, that he himself may be just, and the justifier of him, who is of the faith of Jesus Christ. (Romans 3: 25) A third effect is the remission of sins. 

EXPLANATION OF THE FORM USED IN THE CONSECRATION OF THE WINE 

Since these very words of consecration are replete with mysteries and most appropriately suitable to the subject, they demand a more minute consideration. 

The words: This is the chalice of my blood, are to be understood to mean: This is my blood, which is contained in this chalice.  The mention of the chalice made at the consecration of the blood is right and appropriate, inasmuch as the blood is the drink of the faithful, and this would not be sufficiently signified if it were not contained in some drinking vessel. 

Next follow the words: Of the new testament.  These have been added that we might understand the blood of Christ the Lord to be given not under a figure, as was done in the Old Law, of which we read in the Epistle to the Hebrews (9: 18) that without blood a testament is not dedicated; but to be given to men in truth and in reality, as becomes the New Testament.  Hence the Apostle says: Christ therefore is the mediator of the new testament, that by means of his death, they who are called may receive the promise of eternal inheritance. (Hebrews 9: 15) 

The word eternal refers to the eternal inheritance, the right to which we acquire by the death of Christ the Lord, the eternal testator. 

The words mystery of faith, which are subjoined, do not exclude the reality, but signify that what lies hidden and concealed and far removed from the perception of the eye, is to be believed with firm faith.  In this passage, however, these words bear a meaning different from that which they have when applied also to Baptism.  Here the mystery of faith consists in seeing by faith the blood of Christ veiled under the species of wine; but Baptism is justly called by us the Sacrament of faith, by the Greeks, the mystery of faith, because it embraces the entire profession of the Christian faith. 

Another reason why we call the blood of the Lord the mystery of faith is that human reason is particularly beset with difficulty and embarrassment when faith proposes to our belief that Christ the Lord, the true Son of God, at once God and man, suffered death for us, and this death is designated by the Sacrament of His blood. 

Here, therefore, rather than at the consecration of His body, is appropriately commemorated the Passion of our Lord, by the words, which shall be shed for the remission of sins. For the blood, separately consecrated, serves to place before the eyes of all, in a more forcible manner, the Passion of our Lord, His death, and the nature of His sufferings. 

The additional words for you and for many, are taken, some from Matthew, some from Luke, (Matthew 26: 28; Luke 22: 20) but were joined together by the Catholic Church under the guidance of the Spirit of God.  They serve to declare the fruit and advantage of His Passion.  For if we look to its value, we must confess that the Redeemer shed His blood for the salvation of all; but if we look to the fruit which mankind have received from it, we shall easily find that it pertains not unto all, but to many of the human race.  When therefore (our Lord) said: For you, He meant either those who were present, or those chosen from among the Jewish people, such as were, with the exception of Judas, the disciples with whom He was speaking.  When He added, And for many, He wished to be understood to mean the remainder of the elect from among the Jews or Gentiles. 

With reason, therefore, were the words for all not used, as in this place the fruits of the Passion are alone spoken of, and to the elect only did His Passion bring the fruit of salvation.  And this is the purport of the Apostle (Hebrews 9: 28) when he says: Christ was offered once to exhaust the sins of many; and also of the words of our Lord in John: I pray for them; I pray not for the world, but for them whom thou hast given me, because they are thine. (John 17: 9) 

Beneath the words of this consecration lie hid many other mysteries, which by frequent meditation and study of sacred things, pastors will find it easy, with the divine assistance, to discover for themselves.  (Catechism of Trent [CoT] pages 219 - 225) 

The Obligation of Receiving the Eucharist 

Jesus took the loaves, and when he had given thanks, he distributed to them that were sat down (John 6: 11) 

HOW OFTEN MUST COMMUNION BE RECEIVED? 

Lest any be kept away from Communion by the fear that the requisite preparation is too hard and laborious, the faithful are frequently to b reminded that they are all bound to receive the Holy Eucharist.  Furthermore, the Church has decreed that whoever neglects to approach Holy Communion once a year, at Easter, is liable to sentence of excommunication.  [This was decreed in the Fourth Lateran Council, 1215.  In the New Cod it is found in can. 859.] 

THE CHURCH DESIRES THE FAITHFUL TO COMMUNICATE DAILY 

However, let not the faithful imagine that it is enough to receive the body of the Lord once a year only, in obedience to the decree of the Church.  They should approach oftener; but whether monthly, weekly, or daily, cannot be decided by one fixed universal rule.  Saint Augustine, however, lays down a most certain norm: Live in such a manner as to be able to receive every day. 

It will therefore be the duty of the pastor frequently to admonish the faithful that, as they deem it necessary to afford daily nutriment to the body, they should also feel solicitous to feed and nourish the soul every day with this heavenly food.  It is clear that the soul stands not less in need of spiritual, than the body of corporal food.  Here it will be found most useful to recall the inestimable and divine advantages which, as we have already shown, flow from sacramental Communion.  It will be well also to refer to the manna, which was a figure (of this Sacrament), and which refreshed the bodily powers every day.  (Exodus 16: 21, 22, 4) The Fathers who earnestly recommended the frequent reception of this Sacrament may also be cited.  The words of Saint Augustine, Thou sinnest daily, receive daily, express not his opinion only, but that of all the Fathers who have written on the subject, as anyone may easily discover who will carefully read them. [Frequent Communion is recommended by the following: Augustine, Ignatius, Basil, Cyril, and others at the time this Catechism was first published in 1566] 

That there was a time when the faithful approached Holy Communion every day we learn from the Acts of the Apostles.  All who then professed the faith of Christ burned with such true and sincere charity that, devoting themselves to prayer and other works of piety (Acts 2: 42, 46), they were found prepared to communicate daily.  This devout practice, which seems to have been interrupted for a time, was again partially revived by the holy Pope and martyr Anacletus, who commanded that all the ministers who assisted at the Sacrifice of the Mass should communicate—an ordinance, as the Pontiff declares, of Apostolic institution.  It was also for a long time the practice of the Church that, as soon as the Sacrifice was complete, and when the priest himself had communicated, he turned to the congregation and invited the faithful to the Holy Table in these words: Come, brethren, and receive Communion; and thereupon those who were prepared advanced to receive the holy mysteries with the most fervent devotion. 

THE CHURCH COMMANDS THE FAITHFUL TO COMMUNICATE ONCE A YEAR 

But subsequently, when charity and devotion had grown so cold that the faithful very seldom approached Communion, it was decreed by Pope Fabian [236 – 250], that all should communicate thrice every year, at Christmas, at Easter and at Pentecost.  This decree was afterwards confirmed by many Councils, particularly by the first of Agde. 

Such at length was the decay of piety that not only was this holy and salutary law unobserved, but Communion was deferred for years.  The Council of Lateran, therefore, decreed that all the faithful should receive the sacred body of the Lord, at least once a year, at Easter, and that neglect of this duty should b chastised by exclusion from the society of the faithful. 

WHO ARE OBLIGHED BY THE LAW OF COMMUNION 

But although this law, sanctioned by the authority of God and of His Church, concerns all the faithful, it should be taught that it does not extend to those who on account of their tender age have not attained the use of reason.  For these are not able to distinguish the Holy Eucharist from common and ordinary bread and cannot bring with them to this Sacrament piety and devotion. Furthermore (to extend the precept to them) would appear inconsistent with the ordinance of our Lord, for He said Take and eat (Matthew 26:26)—words which cannot apply to infants, who are evidently incapable of taking and eating. 

In some places, it is true, an ancient practice prevailed of giving the Holy Eucharist even to infants; but, for the reasons already assigned, and for other reasons in keeping with Christian piety, this practice has been long discontinued by the authority of the Church. 

With regard to the age at which children should be given the holy mysteries, this the parents and confessor can best determine.  To them it belongs to inquire and to ascertain from the children themselves whether they have some knowledge of this admirable Sacrament and whether they desire to receive it. [Regarding the Communion of children see Code, can. 854] 

Communion must not be given to persons who are insane and incapable of devotion.  However, according to the decree of the Council of Carthage, it may be administered to them at the close of life, provided they have shown, before losing their minds, a pious and religious disposition, and no danger, arising from the state of the stomach or other inconvenience or disrespect, is likely. (CoT pages 249 – 251) 

Conclusion

The Most Holy Eucharist is the flesh and blood of God.  Pause a moment and let that resonate a bit.  The whole purpose of our existence is to know, love, and serve God in this life so that we may be happy with Him forever in the next.  Salvation is everything.  Christ did so much to make it possible to be saved, but we must do the rest.  He doesn't give us a free ride.  But due to our fallen human nature (Original Sin), salvation is impossible apart from the grace of God and difficult with it.  This should motivate us to do everything we can to ensure our eternal salvation such as always being in the state of grace and receiving the Eucharist devoutly as often as possible as the great Saint Augustine alluded to.  When we receive the Eucharist daily with devotion, we are storing treasures and increasing the grace of God within us, fortifying our souls against future temptations and enabling us to fight the good fight until the end, persevering in the state of sanctifying grace until our dying breaths.  Is there anything more we should demand from the Lord before we start acting as we should?

Monday, November 2, 2026

Contending For The Faith---Part 57

 

In St. Jude 1:3, we read, "Dearly beloved, taking all care to write unto you concerning your common salvation, I was under a necessity to write unto you: to beseech you to contend earnestly for the faith once delivered to the saints." [Emphasis mine]. Contending For The Faith is a series of posts dedicated to apologetics (i.e.,  the intellectual defense of the truth of the Traditional Catholic Faith) to be published the first Monday of each month.  This is the next installment.

Sadly, in this time of Great Apostasy, the faith is under attack like never before, and many Traditionalists don't know their faith well enough to defend it. Remember the words of our first pope, "But in your hearts revere Christ as Lord. Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have. But do this with gentleness and respect..." (1Peter 3:16). There are five (5) categories of attacks that will be dealt with in these posts. Attacks against:
  • The existence and attributes of God
  • The truth of the One True Church established by Christ for the salvation of all 
  • The truth of a particular dogma or doctrine of the Church
  • The truth of Catholic moral teaching
  • The truth of the sedevacantist position as the only Catholic solution to what has happened since Vatican II 
In addition, controversial topics touching on the Faith will sometimes be featured, so that the problem and possible solutions may be better understood. If anyone had suggestions for topics that would fall into any of these categories, you may post them in the comments. I cannot guarantee a post on each one, but each will be carefully considered.

***N.B. Special Note To My Readers: I ask you all in charity to please pray for the mother of one of my long-time readers---Poni. Her mom is seriously ill and needs our prayers for a full return to health and resignation to the Will of God. Please say a special prayer for Poni's mother and for Poni herself, that God may give her strength during this most trying and sorrowful time.

God bless you all, my dear readers---Introibo

Proofs of the Resurrection: Debunking the Conspiracy Hypothesis
There are numerous attempts by the enemies of Christ to deny His physical resurrection from the dead. There are four (4) basic arguments to explain away Christ's resurrection: (1) it was a hallucination of the Apostles; (2) the Apostles created a myth-- they did not mean what they taught to be literal; (3) the Apostles conspired to deceive the world; and (4) Christ didn't really die, he "swooned" and later fully recovered. 

In this post, I will refute the so-called "Conspiracy Hypothesis." (N.B. The information contained in this post comes from myriad sources, both in print and online. I take no credit other than condensing the material into a terse and readable post---Introibo). 

What is The Conspiracy Hypothesis?
The Conspiracy Hypothesis against the resurrection of Christ is also known as the stolen body hypothesis. It claims that Jesus Christ did not rise from the dead, and that His body was instead secretly removed from the tomb by His disciples, who then fabricated the story of a resurrection. According to the Gospel of Saint Matthew (St. Matthew 28:11–15), when the tomb was found empty, the chief priests and elders bribed the Roman guards on duty, telling them to say: "His disciples came by night and stole Him away while we were asleep."

This narrative is one of the earliest recorded alternative explanations to the resurrection, used by critics of Christianity (most notably the Jews) in antiquity to account for the missing Body. Why would Christ's followers steal the Body of Our Lord and conspire to lie about Him rising from the dead? Several reasons are advanced:

• Fulfill Christ's Predictions: They would fabricate a scenario that matched Jesus's earlier prophecies that He would rise after three days. They didn't want to be humiliated that the One they followed did not have His predictions come true. 

• Maintain the Movement: Keep their messianic hopes, authority, or movement alive after the demoralizing shock of His public crucifixion.

• Pious Deceit: Perpetuate a "noble lie" out of devotion or a desire to promote Christ's ethical teachings

The Conspiracy Hypothesis is demonstrably false.

What Constitutes Evidence for Historians?
Historians weigh various factors in assessing competing hypotheses. Some of the most important are as follows:

1.  The best explanation will have greater explanatory scope than other explanations. That is, it will explain more of the evidence.

2.  The best explanation will have greater explanatory power than other explanations. That is, it will make the evidence more probable.

3. The best explanation will be more plausible than other explanations. That is, it will fit better with true background beliefs.

4. The best explanation will be less contrived than other explanations. That is, it won’t require adopting as many new beliefs which have no independent evidence.

5. The best explanation will be disconfirmed by fewer accepted beliefs than other explanations. That is, it won’t conflict with as many accepted beliefs.

6. The best explanation will meet conditions (1)-(5) so much better than the others that there’s little chance that one of the other explanations, after further investigation, will do better in meeting these conditions.

(See C. Behan McCullagh, Justifying Historical Descriptions [1984], pg. 19; Emphasis in original). 

Since a hypothesis may do really well in meeting some conditions but not so well in meeting others, figuring out which hypothesis is the best explanation may often be difficult and requires skill. However, if the explanatory scope and power of a hypothesis are very great, so that it does a much better job in explaining a wide variety of facts, then it’s likely to be the true explanation.

So let’s apply these tests to the typical hypotheses which have been offered down through history to explain the empty tomb, post-mortem appearances, and origin of the disciples’ belief in Jesus’ resurrection, and let’s see if they do better or as well in explaining these facts as the dogma of the Resurrection. 

According to this hypothesis, the disciples stole the body of Jesus and lied about his appearances, thus faking the resurrection. This was the very first counter-explanation for the empty tomb, as we’ve seen, and it was revived during the eighteenth century by European  Deists. Today, however, this explanation has been completely given up by modern scholarship.  We can see why when we assess it by the standard criteria for testing historical hypotheses.

1. Explanatory scope.  The Conspiracy Hypothesis does seem to cover the full scope of the evidence, for it offers explanations of the empty tomb (the disciples stole the body), the post-mortem appearances (the disciples lied about seeing Jesus), and the origin of the disciples’ (supposed) belief in Jesus’ resurrection (again, they lied).

2. Explanatory power.  How probable is the evidence, given the Conspiracy Hypothesis?  Here doubts begin to arise about the adequacy of the hypothesis. 

First, consider the story of the empty tomb.  If the disciples stole Jesus’ corpse, then it would be utterly pointless to fabricate a story about women finding the tomb to be empty.  Such a story would not be the sort of tale Jewish men would invent.  Moreover, the simplicity of the story is not what one would expect, given the Conspiracy Hypothesis—where are the Scriptural proof-texts, the evidence of fulfilled prophecy?  Why isn’t Jesus described as emerging from the tomb, as in later forgeries like the so-called "Gospel of Peter"?  Neither is the dispute with non-believing Jews well-explained.  Why isn’t St. Matthew’s guard already there in St. Mark’s story?  Even in St. Matthew’s story the guard is set too late: the body could have already been stolen before the guard arrived on Saturday morning, so that they were guarding, unbeknownst to them, an empty tomb!  For a failsafe alibi against theft of the body, see again the forged Gospel of Peter, where the guard is set immediately upon interment of the corpse. 

As for the appearance stories, similar problems arise.  A fabricator would probably describe Jesus’ resurrection appearances in terms of Old Testament visions of God and descriptions of the end-time resurrection (as in Daniel 12.2).  But then Jesus should appear to the disciples in dazzling glory.  And why not a description of the resurrection itself?  Why no appearances to Caiaphas the high priest or to the villains on the Sanhedrin, as Jesus predicted?  They could be then branded as the real liars for denying that Jesus did appear to them! 

However, the explanatory power of the Conspiracy Hypothesis is undoubtedly weakest when it comes to the origin of the disciples’ belief in Jesus’ resurrection.  For the hypothesis is really a denial of that fact; it seeks to explain the mere semblance of belief on the disciples’ part.  But as critics have universally recognized, you can’t plausibly deny that the earliest disciples at least sincerely believed that Jesus was risen from the dead. They staked their very lives on that conviction.  The transformation in the lives of the disciples is not credibly explained by the hypothesis of a conspiracy.  This shortcoming alone has been enough in the minds of most scholars to sink the old Conspiracy Hypothesis forever.

3. Plausibility.  The real Achilles’ Heel of the Conspiracy Hypothesis is, however, its implausibility.  One might mention here objections to the unbelievable complexity of such a conspiracy or the supposed psychological state of the disciples; but the overriding problem that dwarfs all others is that it is wholly anachronistic to suppose that first century Jews intended to hoax Jesus’ resurrection.  The Conspiracy Hypothesis views the disciples’ situation through the rearview mirror of Christian history rather than through the eyes of a first century Jew. 

In the first place, there was no expectation in Judaism of a Messiah who, instead of establishing David’s throne and subduing Israel’s enemies, would be shamefully executed by the Gentiles as a criminal.  Moreover, the Jewish idea of resurrection was just unconnected with the idea of Messiah and even incompatible with it, since Messiah was not supposed to be killed.  As N. T. Wright nicely puts it, if you’re a first century Jew, and your favorite Messiah got himself crucified, then you’ve basically got two choices: either you go home or else you get yourself a new Messiah.

Secondly, the Jewish conception of resurrection of the dead differed in at least two fundamental respects from the resurrection of Jesus.

 It is a fact that in Jewish thinking the resurrection to glory and immortality always occurred after the end of the world.  Jews had no idea of a resurrection within history. That’s why, I think, the disciples had so much trouble understanding Jesus’ predictions of his own resurrection. They thought he was talking about the resurrection at the end of the world. Look at St. Mark 9:9-11, for example:

And as they were coming down from the mountain, He gave them orders not to relate to anyone what they had seen, until the Son of Man should rise from the dead. And they seized upon that statement, discussing with one another what rising from the dead might mean. And they began questioning Him, saying, “Why is it that the scribes say that first Elijah must come?”

Here Jesus predicts His resurrection, and what do the disciples ask? “Why is it that the scribes say that first Elijah must come?” In first century Judaism it was believed the prophet Elijah would come again before the great and terrible Day of the Lord, the judgment day when the dead would be raised. The disciples could not understand the idea of a resurrection occurring within history prior to the end of the world. Hence, Jesus’ predictions only confused them.

Thus, given the Jewish conception of the resurrection, the disciples after Jesus’ crucifixion would not have come up with the strange idea that he had been already raised. They would in all probability have looked forward to the resurrection at the last day and, in keeping with Jewish custom, perhaps preserved his tomb as a shrine where his bones could rest until the resurrection.

Secondly, in Jewish thinking the resurrection was always the resurrection of all the righteous dead.  Jews had no idea of the resurrection of an isolated individual apart from the general resurrection. Moreover, there was simply no connection between the individual believer’s resurrection and the prior resurrection of the Messiah.  That’s why we find no examples of other failed messianic movements claiming that their executed leader was risen from the dead. 

First century Jews had no idea of the resurrection of an isolated individual, especially of the Messiah, in advance of the general resurrection at the end of the world.  So the idea of stealing Jesus’ corpse and saying that God had raised him from the dead is hardly one that would have entered the minds of these Jewish disciples of Jesus nor seemed to them a plausible strategy for evangelizing their fellow Jews!

What about influences from outside Judaism?  A suggestion widespread on the Internet today is that early Christians came up with the idea of Jesus’ resurrection through the influence of pagan mythology.  This suggestion is an old one.  Back around the turn of the 19th to the 20th century, scholars in comparative religion collected parallels to Christian beliefs in other religious movements, and some even thought to explain Christian beliefs, including the belief in Jesus’ resurrection, as the result of the influence of such myths. The movement soon collapsed, however, principally due to two factors:

(a) Scholars came to realize that the parallels are false.  The ancient world was a virtual fruit basket of myths of various gods and heroes.  Comparative studies in religion require sensitivity to their similarities and differences, or distortion and confusion inevitably result.  Unfortunately, those who were eager to find parallels to Jesus’ resurrection failed to exercise such sensitivity. 

Many of the alleged parallels are actually stories of the assumption of the hero into heaven (Hercules, Romulus).  Others are disappearance stories, which claim that the hero has vanished into a higher sphere (Apollonius of Tyana, Empedocles).  Still others are seasonal symbols for the crop cycle, as the vegetation dies in the dry season and comes back to life in the rainy season (Tammuz, Osiris, Adonis). Some are political expressions of Emperor worship (Julius Caesar, Caesar Augustus).

None of these ideas is parallel to the Jewish idea of the resurrection of the dead.  Indeed, most scholars have come to doubt whether, properly speaking, there really were any myths of dying and rising gods at all. For example, in the myth of Osiris, which was one of the best known symbolic seasonal myths, Osiris doesn’t really come back to life but simply continues to exist in the realm of the dead. 

Scholars have come to realize that pagan mythology is simply the wrong interpretive context for understanding Jesus of Nazareth. Jesus and his disciples were first century Israelite Jews, and it is against that background that they must be understood.  The collapse of the alleged parallels is just one indication that pagan mythology is the wrong interpretive context for understanding the disciples’ belief in Jesus’ resurrection.

(b) There is in any case no causal connection between the pagan myths and the origin of the disciples’ belief in Jesus’ resurrection.  Jews were familiar with the seasonal pagan deities (Ezekiel 8.14-15) and found them abhorrent.  That’s why there is no trace of cults of dying and rising gods at all in first century Israel.  It’s pretty unlikely that the original disciples would have come up with the idea that Jesus of Nazareth was risen from the dead because they had heard pagan myths about dying and rising seasonal deities. So scholars have universally abandoned this approach.  Internet sceptics are over 100 years out of date.

Notice that this criticism undermines not only conspiracy theories, which suppose that the disciples insincerely proclaimed Jesus’ resurrection, but also any theory which suggests that, on the basis of pagan or Jewish influences, they sincerely came to believe in and preached his resurrection.

4. Less contrived.  Like all conspiracy theories of history, the Conspiracy Hypothesis is contrived in supposing that what all the evidence seems to point to is, in fact, mere appearance only, to be explained away by hypotheses for which there is no evidence.  Specifically, it postulates motives and ideas in the minds of the earliest disciples and actions on their part for which there is not a shred of evidence.  It can become even more contrived, as hypotheses have to be multiplied to deal with objections to the theory, for example, how to account for the appearance to the 500 brethren or the women’s role in the empty tomb and appearance stories.

5. Disconfirmed by fewer accepted beliefs.  The Conspiracy Hypothesis tends to be disconfirmed by our general knowledge of conspiracies, their instability and tendency to unravel.  Moreover, it is disconfirmed by accepted beliefs such as the sincerity of the disciples, the nature of first century Jewish messianic expectations, and so on.

6. Exceeds other hypotheses in fulfilling conditions (1)-(5).  This condition is obviously not met, since there are better hypotheses (such as the Hallucination Hypothesis), which don’t dismiss the disciples’ belief in Jesus’ resurrection as a blatant lie.

No scholar would defend the Conspiracy Hypothesis today. The only place you read about such things is in the popular, sensationalist press or on the Internet.

Conclusion

The Conspiracy Hypothesis has no plausibility. Consider the Apostles behavior after the resurrection. The change in their lives from fear to faith, despair to confidence, confusion to certitude, runaway cowardice to steadfast boldness under threat and persecution, not only proves their sincerity but testifies to some powerful cause of it. Can a lie cause such a transformation? Obviously not. The physical resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead is a fact of history and not some conspiratorial fraud.