Monday, March 8, 2021

They Are No Longer Two, But One Flesh

 

A few weeks back, I wrote a post concerning the vocation of the single life, a much maligned and misunderstood state of life. (See introiboadaltaredei2.blogspot.com/2020/12/single-minded-devotion.html). I explained how the Church teaches that all are called to one of four vocations: the priesthood, the religious life (nuns, brothers, monks), the married state, and the single state. In this post, I will discuss the joys and trials of the married vocation; an institution under greater attack than at any other point in history. Of the four vocations, only Holy Matrimony and Holy Orders are Sacraments instituted by Our Lord Jesus Christ. 

Unfortunately, Matrimony is not given the respect and recognition due to a Sacrament by most individuals and by society in general. As of this writing, the United States (along with many other countries--some even strongly Catholic before Vatican II) recognize the coupling of sodomites as "marriage." They dare to sully with the name "marriage" two perverts committing acts against God and nature. On another front of attack, how many times have I heard men denigrate their wives as their "ball and chain" and women insulting their husbands as "the jerk at home." Such appellations, whether done in jest or seriously, cast aspersions upon marriage. Not least of all, we have Jorge Bergoglio allowing "communion" from his sect to be given to divorced and "remarried" adulterers.  Good marriages are the backbone of any civilization, especially those that aim to be Christian.  With this in mind, I will discuss the married vocation as it is taught by the Church.

(For the material on the sacramental and dogmatic aspects of Holy Matrimony, I have used theologian Schleck, The Sacrament of Matrimony, [1963] and theologian Riley, Sanctity and Success in Marriage, [1956]. For the practical aspects of marriage, I have used the personal correspondence between myself and Fr. Gommar A. DePauw, JCD (my spiritual father); a pre-Vatican II approved canonist who counseled me when I started thinking about the possibility of marriage at some point in my future. At the time, he also had 60 years of counseling couples in preparation for the Sacrament of  Holy Matrimony, and in helping them with the difficulties they faced. I also reference the notes of a great Traditionalist priest (ordained pre-Vatican II), with whom I happened to meet and speak with around that same time. Both have since gone to Judgement. If you get anything worthwhile from this post, please say a prayer for the repose of the souls of these two magnificent priests.---Introibo). 

Matrimony: Natural and Sacramental

1. Matrimony was ordained by God for the perpetuation of the Human Race since Creation.

Sacred Scripture tells us that marriage came to us as a design of the Creator. The account in the Book of Genesis explicitly teaches that the union of man and woman in marriage was instituted by God. In the account, the rib is mentioned in order to show the identity of nature in Adam and Eve and to give point to the doctrine on marriage. It seems to have been the mind of the sacred writer to explain the religious mystery and origin and distinction of the sexes within the same human nature, with a view to their reunion in marriage, and this as the design of God Himself. It also shows that the man is called to be the head of the family unit, and the woman its heart. 

The Catechism of the Council of Trent cites to this event in Genesis as proof that marriage was Divinely instituted:

The faithful, therefore, are to be taught in the first place that marriage was instituted by God. We read in Genesis that God created them male and female, and blessed them, saying: "Increase and multiply"; and also: "It is not good for man to be alone: let us make him a help like unto himself.,' And a little further on: But for Adam there was not found a helper like himself. Then the Lord God cast a deep sleep upon Adam; and when he was fast asleep, he took one of his ribs, and filled up flesh for it. And the Lord God built a rib which he took from Adam. into a woman, and brought her to Adam; and Adam said: "This is now bone of my bones, and flesh of my flesh: she shall be called woman, because she was taken out of man: wherefore a man shall leave father and mother, and shall cleave to his wife; and they shall be two in one flesh," These words, according to the authority of our Lord Himself, as we read in St. Matthew, prove the divine institution of Matrimony.

2. Matrimony was raised to the status of a Sacrament by Our Lord Jesus Christ. 

The Council of Trent infallibly decreed:

CANON I-- If anyone says that matrimony is not truly and properly one of the seven sacraments of the evangelical law, instituted by Christ the Lord, but has been devised by men in the Church and does not confer grace, let him be anathema.

The main argument for the sacramentality of Christian marriage is derived by the Council of Trent from the teaching of the early writers of the Church, from the early Councils, and from the universal belief and practice of the Church. Sacred Tradition, we know, contains many doctrines revealed by Christ and taught by the Apostles which were not committed in writing to the pages of the New Testament. It is impossible to state precisely when our Blessed Lord made marriage a Sacrament. Some theologians teach that He did so on the occasion of the marriage feast at Cana. Other theologians are of the opinion that marriage was raised to sacramental dignity when Christ promulgated the indissolubility of marriage. Yet still other theologians teach that marriage was made a Sacrament by our Divine Lord during the period of the forty days between His Resurrection and Ascension when, as the Acts of the Apostles says, He frequently spoke to His disciples "of the kingdom of God."

4. Marriage is a state that is good, holy, and praiseworthy.

In his encyclical Arcanum Divinae, Pope Leo XIII taught:

Marriage has God for its Author, and was from the very beginning a kind of foreshadowing of the Incarnation of His Son; and therefore there abides in it a something holy and religious; not extraneous, but innate; not derived from men, but implanted by nature. Innocent III, therefore, and Honorius III, our predecessors, affirmed not falsely nor rashly that a sacrament of marriage existed ever amongst the faithful and unbelievers... As, then, marriage is holy by its own power, in its own nature, and of itself, it ought not to be regulated and administered by the will of civil rulers, but by the divine authority of the Church, which alone in sacred matters professes the office of teaching. (para. #19; Emphasis mine). 

Heretics have always assailed marriage as an evil to be avoided or merely tolerated. Hence, the Encratities forbade marriage (See 1 Timothy 4:1-3); the Gnostics rejected matter and exalted spirit, holding matrimony in disrepute; Montanists forbade widows and widowers to enter second marriages; and Pricillianists, who taught matter inherently evil, outright condemned matrimony. All those teachings were condemned by the Church.  However, it must be remembered:

  • Matrimony is not necessary for salvation
  • No one is obliged to choose the marital vocation
  • Marriage is inferior to the more excellent states of virginity and celibacy
As to the last point, the Council of Trent infallibly decreed:

CANON X.-If any one saith, that the marriage state is to be placed above the state of virginity, or of celibacy, and that it is not better and more blessed to remain in virginity, or in celibacy, than to be united in matrimony; let him be anathema.

Sacramental Theology of Holy Matrimony

1. Matter, Form, Minister, and Intention

Although never defined, it is the certain teaching of the theologians (following such greats as Bellarmine and Suarez)  that the matter and form are contained in the marriage contract. (See theologian Pohle, Dogmatic Theology, [1924], 11:165-167). The contract and Sacrament are inseparable. When the baptized couple enter into a lifelong indissoluble contract giving rights over each others' body, the words or signs of consent are the matter insofar  as they signify the mutual surrender of bodies, and its form insofar as it signifies the acceptance of same. As a logical corollary, the couple are the ministers of the Sacrament to each other, and the priest functions as the necessary witness of the Church. Traditionalist Catholics who attempt to contract marriage before a civil official or a clergyman of a false sect are not validly married since members of the One True Church are bound to get married in the canonical form prescribed by the Church. 

In addition, for a valid Sacramental marriage between Traditionalist Catholics, both validly baptized parties must have at least an implicit virtual intention to enter into a marriage contract. The female must be at least 14 years of age and the male 16 years of age. Just as the Sacrament of the Holy Eucharist does not consist in the consecration alone, but continues as a Sacrament as long as the species of bread and wine remain, so too, according to this view taught by numerous theologians, Matrimony as a Sacrament does not consist in the wedding rite alone, but continues as a Sacrament as long as the marital bond remains. Pope Pius XI seems to give his authoritative approval of this view in his encyclical Casti Connubii :

 Let them constantly keep in mind, that they have been sanctified and strengthened for the duties and for the dignity of their state by a special Sacrament, the efficacious power of which, although it does not impress a character, is undying. To this purpose we may ponder over the words, full of real comfort, of holy Cardinal Robert Bellarmine, who with other well known theologians with devout conviction thus expresses himself: 'The Sacrament of Matrimony can be regarded in two ways: first, in the making, and then in its permanent state. For it is a Sacrament like to that of the Eucharist, which not only when it is being conferred, but also whilst it remains, is a Sacrament; for as long as the married parties are alive, so long is their union a Sacrament of Christ and the Church.(para. #110)

From the doctrine of the sacramental nature of every valid marriage contracted by baptized persons, it follows that two baptized non-Catholics may not only enter a true marriage, but even receive the Sacrament of Matrimony. Two unbaptized people who are free to marry are capable of contracting a true and valid marriage. Of course, such a marriage will not be sacramental, for no one is ever capable of receiving any other Sacrament unless first the character of Baptism has been imprinted on his soul. A natural, non-Sacramental marriage can only be dissolved by the Pauline Privilege (e.g., two validly married Jews wherein one converts to the True Church and the other will not leave them in peace. In such a case, the Church may dissolve the marriage).

2. Properties of Sacramental Marriage

(a) Unity. Marriage is monogamous. Polygamy and polyandry are abominations. The family unit demands one husband with one wife for the raising of children. An objection often raised is the case of the Israelites who practiced bigamy. There are two solutions proposed. One states that God gave a dispensation from the Natural Law as in the case of the Pauline Privilege. (this was favored by Aquinas). However, since the time of Trent, the majority of theologians hold that since it is perfectly possible over many years since the Fall of the First Parents that secondary precepts of the Natural Law may become obscured, it seems more likely God tolerated the practice rather than gave a dispensation. 

The Council of Trent infallibly decreed:

CANON II--If anyone says that it is lawful for Christians to have several wives at the same time and that this is not forbidden by any divine law, let him be anathema.

(b) Indissolubility. 

A Sacramental Marriage, once ratified before the Church, and consummated by the first act of sexual intercourse thereafter (i.e., ratum et consummatum), can never be ended by anything but the death of at least one spouse. Divorce is impossible. Christ tells us there was no divorce from the beginning, and He was to restore the indissolubility of Matrimony. 

In the Gospel according to St. Matthew 19:3-9, we read:

And there came to Him the Pharisees tempting him, and saying: Is it lawful for a man to put away his wife for every cause? Who answering, said to them: Have ye not read, that he who made man from the beginning, Made them male and female? And He said: For this cause shall a man leave father and mother, and shall cleave to his wife, and they two shall be in one flesh. Therefore now they are not two, but one flesh. What therefore God hath joined together, let no man put asunder. They say to Him: Why then did Moses command to give a bill of divorce, and to put away? He saith to them: Because Moses by reason of the hardness of your heart permitted you to put away your wives: but from the beginning it was not so And I say to you, that whosoever shall put away his wife, except it be for fornication, and shall marry another, committeth adultery: and he that shall marry her that is put away, committeth adultery. (Emphasis mine). 

Yet, doesn't Christ allow divorce for adultery? In a word: No. "Fornication" (or rendered "adultery" in all Protestant bibles) doesn't allow for such divorce. As theologian Pohle explains, since Christ was to elevate marriage to the way it was at the beginning, if He allowed an exception for adultery, that would mean an innocent woman would be forbidden to remarry if her husband divorced her, but if she commits adultery, they would both be free to marry again. This would be (a) an incentive to sin, and (b) making the Old Testament practice superior to the New Testament of Christ which is impossible. Correctly understood, it means you can separate bed and board for adultery and serious offences (wife beating, etc) but divorce is forbidden. 

The reason for this absolute indissolubility is that only of a properly consummated Christian marriage can it be said in the full sense of the phrase that husband and wife are "two in one flesh" and that their union is a perfect symbol of Christ's mystic union with His Church, consummated by the Incarnation. (See Pohle, Ibid, pgs. 183-200). 

3. Purposes of Marriage.

The primary purpose of Matrimony is the procreation and education of children. The secondary purpose is mutual help/love and support for the spouses. The Code of Canon Law (1917), Canon 1013 section 1 states, "The primary end of marriage is the procreation and education of children.  It’s secondary end is mutual help and the allaying of concupiscence." The primary purpose does not imply that the wife must have as many children as she is physically capable of bearing. If this were the case, it would mean that the Church was wrong (and promoted evil) by allowing the marriages of (a) those who, through no fault of their own, were infertile, and (b) elderly widows way beyond their child-bearing years. 

(For more on this issue see my post introiboadaltaredei2.blogspot.com/2019/10/multiplication-problems.html). 

4. Graces of the Sacrament.

According to theologian Schleck, Matrimony (1) increases sanctifying grace, and (2) gives a right to receive actual graces, which God bestows, to aid a spouse whenever needed for fulfillment of the duties inherent in the vocation of Matrimony. (See Schleck, pgs. 197-198). 

Discerning a Vocation to the Marital State

Pope Pius XI warned about things you must avoid when considering marriage:

To the proximate preparation of a good married life belongs very specially the care in choosing a partner; on that depends a great deal whether the forthcoming marriage will be happy or not, since one may be to the other either a great help in leading a Christian life, or, a great danger and hindrance. And so that they may not deplore for the rest of their lives the sorrows arising from an indiscreet marriage, those about to enter into wedlock should carefully deliberate in choosing the person with whom henceforward they must live continually: they should, in so deliberating, keep before their minds the thought first of God and of the true religion of Christ, then of themselves, of their partner, of the children to come, as also of human and civil society, for which wedlock is a fountain head. Let them diligently pray for divine help, so that they make their choice in accordance with Christian prudence, not indeed led by the blind and unrestrained impulse of lust, nor by any desire of riches or other base influence, but by a true and noble love and by a sincere affection for the future partner; and then let them strive in their married life for those ends for which the State was constituted by God.(See Casti Connubii, para. #115; Emphasis mine). 

As always, pray to God for His guidance in discerning the vocation He has chosen for you. Marriage is unique insofar as you will either be in a good marriage and be very happy, or you will end up in a bad marriage and be very miserable. There really is no in-between. The reason is clear. In marriage, you need to work with your partner and God's grace to make it successful, and there is no guarantee the other person will be willing to work with you. In the priesthood and the religious life (especially in a time of sedevacante) you can always work things out with your order/bishop or continue on your own if needed. As a single person, you need not work with anyone but your boss at work and God. Marriage takes two--always. 

Here are some wrong reasons to want to get married:

  • desiring to have sex and keep a good reputation
  • wanting to be like your friends who are married
  • pressure from parents and relatives
  • not to be looked upon as "odd" after a certain age
  • using it as a "fall back" position if denied entrance into a convent or seminary
  • because you are lonely
The only really good reason to get married is because you feel God has called you to be a good wife/mother or husband/father, for the good of the Church and to help you achieve salvation by so doing.

Choosing a Spouse

If you decide the marital vocation is for you, the choice of a spouse is of paramount importance.  You must have a union on three levels, physical, mental, and spiritual. 

  • Physically: There must be attraction, but don't mistake infatuation or lust for love. Anyone who has a reputation for sleeping around, or who has cheated on a former boyfriend/girlfriend should never be considered. Do they take reasonable good care of their body? You might want to think twice about considering as a spouse someone who drinks to excess or smokes. A drug addict should be shown the door to leave. Differences in ethnic/racial background and/or age can be problematic--be wary of a large age difference (usually more than ten years). Are you being pressured for sex? Were/Are they into any sexual perversions or approve of sodomites and/or transgenders?
  • Mentally: Do you have comparable intelligence and education? If not, you will have a hard time finding mutual interests. It's not necessarily a "deal breaker," but rarely will a highly educated professional have enough in common with a person who has little education and a blue collar job. Do you have similar artistic tastes, and like the same activities? Do you have the same view towards work and money? You can't expect to marry your "opposite sex double" who thinks exactly like you, but having common interests, goals, and outlooks is very important.
  • Spiritually: This is most important of the three. Is the person a Traditionalist? Since finding a member of the One True Church is not as easy as before the Great Apostasy, most Traditionalist clergy will more readily allow mixed marriages as long as the promises are signed as per Canon Law (they must swear not to interfere with your religious practice, and agree that all children will be raised in the True Church exclusively). Are they willing to convert? Open to going to Mass with you? Are you morally certain the promises will be kept? Do they understand sedevacantism, especially if a member of the Vatican II sect? Do they ever dabble in the occult? Will they pressure you in going to their sect in the name of "fairness"? Is the person considered virtuous by you and most others?

 Other significant things to consider:

  • Ask your parents and close friends what they think. They can often be more objective than you in assessing someone you are considering marrying
  • Do they have a steady job and show maturity and responsibility?
  • Beware of anyone who keeps secrets or gets caught in a lie
  • Abusive behavior towards you in any form (mental, emotional, or physical) should be someone from whom you walk away and never look back
  • Do they have children out of wedlock?
  • Were they married invalidly (by a civil judge, etc)? Why did the marriage fail?
Dangers to Anticipate that Assail Marriages of Today
According to the American Psychological Association (APA) about 40 to 50 percent of married couples in the United States divorce (See apa.org/topics/divorce-child-custody). Here are some major reasons:

1. The home becomes a "service station."
Just as a car pulls into a service station for gas and you also check tire pressure before taking off, many families treat their homes in similar fashion. Children come home, eat dinner before (or after) play dates and activities. The husband/father comes home to fix the house, while the working mother (not always working out of necessity) doesn't want to deal with the kids. In God's plan, your home is not an extension of the YMCA where you can eat, shower, and sleep. You need time together to really get to know each other, talk together, pray together, and help each other.

2. Artificial entertainment.
 Lack of communication is a killer for a marriage and a happy family life. Restrict time and access on iPhone, iPad, TV, listening to music, etc. Know everything your children access and limit their time, in order that they may have live interaction in  the world. Husbands and wives must communicate and form common interests or they will "grow apart" --to use the common parlance expression. This will lead to an unhappy married life.

3. Adultery.
Married men and women are exposed to filth in all areas of secular life and it makes it seem that adultery is "no big deal." This is a very dangerous mindset.  Married men have no business keeping company with women other than their wives, and married women have no business keeping company with men other than their husbands. It is fine to be together with other married couples where all spouses are present. Office parties, celebrations at a friend or neighbor's house, etc., should only be attended with your spouse or not at all. According to the University of Colorado, about 21 percent of men and 13 percent of women reported infidelity at some point in their lifetime. Just over half (53.5 percent) of those reporting extramarital sex said they were unfaithful with someone they knew well, such as a close friend. About a third of affairs are with someone who’s somewhat well-known, such as a neighbor, co-worker or long-term acquaintance (about 29.4 percent). (See colorado.edu/asmagazine/2018/04/04/extramarital-sex-partners-likely-be-close-friends-and-men-are-more-apt-cheat). Adultery is one of the most wicked sins as it betrays someone you profess to love and violates a sacred vow made before God and His Church. Personally, I have never been able to remain friends with someone who was an adulterer, nor would I become friends with someone whom I knew had cheated on their wife. I think to myself, "If he could betray his very spouse and turn his back on God by breaking sacred vows, what would/could he do to betray me?"

Marital Joys and Sorrows
As with the other vocations, marriage brings joys, and also crosses to bear. Here is a partial listing of both.

Joys of Marriage. Positive aspects of this vocation:
  • You have a life-long partner to come home to and share everything. They can help you achieve eternal salvation by their prayers, sacrifices, and good example
  • You have support in difficult times
  • You bring new life into the world and help them to become future citizens of Heaven by raising them to know, love, and serve God in His One True Church
  • Children can support you in your old age if you get sickly, instead of going into a nursing home
  • You may have positive relationships with your spouse's family members
  • You will rarely, if ever, be lonely
Sorrows of Marriage. Negative aspects of this vocation:
  • If your spouse leaves you, or if you are forced by abuse to separate bed and board, you can never remarry as long as your spouse lives, but must remain celibate. A civil divorce in such a case would cause irreparable damage to any children--as all divorce is harmful, especially to children
  • Raising children, especially in today's anti-Christian, neo-pagan environment is very difficult. It is hard to keep them on the straight path to Heaven, and God will hold you responsible for their upbringing. Many times both spouses need to work, making raising good Traditionalist children even harder.
  • If there is no Traditionalist school, and homeschooling is not an option, children must go to pagan public schools (schools of false sects are even worse, and you cannot send them to receive false doctrines)
  • Your life is not your own. Your children come first, your spouse second, and you are last. This means little individual freedom to pursue hobbies, interests, spend time with friends, etc. Often family considerations will prevent vacations, the ability to change jobs, or pursue advanced education
  • You may not get along with your spouse's family
  • You most likely will have to work more and retire later
  • You need to be able to work with your spouse. If he/she is unwilling, constant fighting will inevitably occur

Conclusion
Whether of not to get married is one of the most important decisions a Traditionalist must make. Trying to find the right person to marry is just as important, and in many ways more difficult in these evil times. In his book, Marriage: Human or Divine?, (1940), theologian O'Connell had the following to say about Holy Matrimony, which all married couples, and those considering marriage, should contemplate:

The truth that Christian marriage is a sacrament should be deeply impressed on the minds of all Catholics intending to get married or already joined in marriage. The former should be impressed with the thought that they are about to receive one of the seven efficacious means of grace established by our divine Redeemer to bestow abundant supernatural helps on the children of men for the needs of life's journey. The latter should realize that they are bound to each other in a union that bears a close resemblance to the union between Christ and His Church. The chief characteristics of this latter union are generosity and love. Christ generously gave His very life for the Church because of His unbounded love for every human soul; and the Church is constantly laboring devotedly for the glory of Christ and expressing its love for Him, dwelling in her midst in the sacrament of the altar. Surely, then, Catholic married couples should deeply appreciate the honor their marriage enjoys in representing the union between the heavenly Bridegroom, Jesus Christ, and His earthly spouse, the Church, and should endeavor to live up to this honor by ever manifesting toward each other an unselfish devotion and an ardent love. (pg. 17). 


Monday, March 1, 2021

When Strangers Come Knocking---Part 19

 

This is the next installment of my series to be published the first Monday of each month.

There are members of false sects, like Jehovah's Witnesses, that come knocking door-to-door hoping to convert you. Instead of ignoring them, it is we who should try and convert them. In 1 Peter 3:16, our first Pope writes, "But in thy hearts revere Christ as Lord. Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks thee to give the reason for the hope that thou hast. But do this with gentleness and respect,..." Before the Great Apostasy, the Church would send missionaries to the ends of the Earth to make as many converts as possible. 

Those in false religions don't always come (literally) knocking at your door. It may be a Hindu at work who wants you to try yoga. It could be a "Christian Scientist" who lives next door and invites you to come to their reading room. Each month, I will present a false sect. Unlike the Vatican II sect, I do not see them as a "means of salvation" or possessing "elements of truth" that lead to salvation. That is heresy. They lead to damnation, and the adherents of the various sects must be converted so they may be saved.

In each month's post, I will present one false sect and give an overview of: 

  • The sect's history
  • Their theology
  • Tips on how to share the True Faith with them
The Chopra Center for Well Being
A religion is usually considered by sociologists as having "a creed (beliefs), a code (ethical standards), and a cult (way of worship)." Some add a "fourth C" for "community structure." Many sects are obviously religions, such as Islam, Mormonism, etc. Other sects are not so obvious. They don't claim the status of a religion or have formal clergy. Nevertheless, they have devoted followers who believe what they teach, and follow what they're told to do. The followers may even claim to belong to a formal religion, but the sect shapes their views in spite of such membership. 

Such is the case of Deepak Chopra (b. 1947), an Indian medical doctor who has become, what I consider, a quasi-cult leader. Chopra abandoned traditional medicine for so-called "alternative medicine," and spouts gibberish that won him admiration, followers, and lots of money. His net worth has been estimated by some at $150 million, and by other sources at $80 million. (See, e.g., therichest.com/celebnetworth/celeb/authors/deepak-chopra-net-worth/). In either case his blathering has made him a fortune. 

Read this quote of Chopra: "Research has shown that the best way to be happy is to make each day happy." Compare: "Our consciousness is mirrored in descriptions of potentiality." While both are equally asinine, the former is real (See brainyquote.com/quotes/deepak_chopra_453953), while the latter comes from a satire site wisdomofchopra.com which states:

It has been said by some that the thoughts and tweets of Deepak Chopra are indistinguishable from a set of profound sounding words put together in a random order, particularly the tweets tagged with "#cosmisconciousness". This site aims to test that claim! Each "quote" is generated from a list of words that can be found in Deepak Chopra's Twitter stream randomly stuck together in a sentence.(N.B. While I agree that Chopra is no profound thinker, and the website makes that point in a very clever manner, the site owner is antithetical to all religion---calling himself a "skeptic"---and my use of the quote generator is not be be considered an endorsement of said website---Introibo). 

In this post, I will expose Chopra's blend of New Age thought, Hinduism, and pseudo-science, which had caused more than one person to accept his false version of Christ. 

The Medical Guru
Deepak Chopra was born in New Delhi, India to a wealthy Hindu family. His father was a respected cardiologist at the time and encouraged his son to follow the same path. Chopra, however, had other ideas: he wanted to become a journalist or actor. Ultimately, he chose to become a physician like his father. In 1964, he entered medical school in India, and became a village doctor. He got married to his wife, Rita, in 1970 and came to the United States. In 1973 he became a licensed physician and Board Certified endocrinologist. 

Dr. Chopra rose quickly in his profession. By 1980, New England Memorial Hospital named Deepak Chopra Chief-of-Staff. His life would change forever in 1981 during a trip back to his native India, when Chopra was introduced to ayurveda, an ancient Indian "folk medicine" (i.e., pagan) tradition. Ayurveda would prove to provide the basis for Chopra’s future theories. As a result of stress tied to his role as a physician, Chopra reports drinking and smoking heavily while on staff at New England Memorial Hospital. Having become skeptical of traditional medicine, he turned to ayurvedic medicine to combat these problems. (See Hans Baer, “The Work of Andrew Weil and Deepak Chopra – Two Holistic Health/New Age Gurus: A Critique of the Holistic Health/New Age Movements.” Medical Anthropology Quarterly 2:233-50).  

Upon his return to the United States, Chopra read a book on Transcendental Meditation  (aka "TM") which was sweeping the nation during the 1980s. Fascinated by this pagan form of meditation, Chopra attended a seminar conducted by Maharishi Mahesh Yogi (b. Mahesh Prasad Varma in 1918, d. 2008), the so-called “father of Transcendental Meditation.” Maharishi Mahesh Yogi was dedicated to the demon "gods" of Hinduism. His rise to fame and fortune began in the late 1960s when he taught his system to the evil rock group The Beatles and later to the also infamous group, The Beach Boys.

Allegedly, the combination of TM and Ayurveda caused a dramatic personal transformation. (Ibid)
In 1985, he left traditional medicine to open the Maharishi Ayurveda Health Center for Stress Management in Lancaster, Massachusetts. (As of this writing, Chopra is still licensed to practice medicine in both Massachusetts and California).  Deepak Chopra published his first book, entitled Quantum Healing, in 1989. The book describes ways in which to heal the body from within using "quantum mechanics." The next book published was Unconditional Life: Discovering the Power to Fulfill Your Dreams. These writings took off and made Chopra a household name after Chopra appeared on the Oprah Winfrey Show in 1991 to promote them and his esoteric pagan ideas. 

In 1993, Chopra left Maharishi’s company and began working for Sharp Health Care as the Executive Director at their Institute for Human Potential and Mind-Body Medicine, only to leave three years later to found his own organization, The Chopra Center of Well Being. Chopra's whacky beliefs will be examined next. 

A "Well Being" That is Dangerous to Mind, Body, and Soul
 “Ayurvedic medicine” is a method of diagnosis and treatment based upon a Hindu approach not only to the body but to life in general. The word ayuvedic comes from two Sanskrit words that roughly translate as "knowledge of life." Chopra is the most infamous and ardent medical pro­moter of this uniquely Hindu approach to medical care. Physically, the approach of ayurveda can be divided into three basic categories:
  •  well-established health principles (adequate rest, sleep, exercise, nutrition, etc.)
  • use of “natural” remedies such as herbs and plants which are codified in numer­ous ayurvedic texts
  • ideas, concepts and treatments that can only be consid­ered unscientific or occultic
Since the first two categories are unobjectionable, and even make good sense, traditional medical doctors don't care about the spiritual implications of the third category which pervades the whole system. Occult practices in medicine have now infiltrated even the best places in traditional medicine. The prestigious Johns Hopkins Medical Center has this to say:

 In India, Ayurveda is considered a form of medical care, equal to conventional Western medicine, traditional Chinese medicine, naturopathic medicine, and homeopathic medicine. Practitioners of Ayurveda in India undergo state-recognized, institutionalized training. Currently, Ayurvedic practitioners are not licensed in the United States, and there is no national standard for Ayurvedic training or certification. However, Ayurvedic schools have gained approval as educational institutions in some states.  (See hopkinsmedicine.org/health/wellness-and-prevention/ayurveda; Emphasis mine).

Johns Hopkins apparently sees no problem with this:
The concepts of universal interconnectedness, the body's constitution (prakriti), and life forces (doshas) are the primary basis of ayurvedic medicine. (Ibid). 

Also:
Many Ayurvedic materials have not been thoroughly studied in either Western or Indian research. Some of the products used in Ayurvedic medicine contain herbs, metals, minerals, or other materials that may be harmful if used improperly or without the direction of a trained practitioner. Ayurvedic medicines are regulated as dietary supplements rather than as drugs in the United States, so they are not required to meet the safety and efficacy standards for conventional medicines. These medicines can interact, or work against, the effects of Western medicines. Investigate the training and background of Ayurvedic practitioners whom you intend to use. (Ibid; Emphasis mine).

Here, we clearly see that the non-scientific and non-medicinal concepts ("prakriti," doshas," etc.) are glossed over, while it is admitted that (a) much of ayurveda has not been thoroughly studied; (b) some products used can be harmful; (c) the materials are not required to meet the safety and efficacy standards of traditional medicine; (d) ayurvedic "practitioners" have no license and objective measures of education and training; yet you, the patient, are somehow expected to "investigate the training and background" of people who are basically on the same level as the Native American "medicine man." People should be warned to stay away, and would have been so warned only thirty years ago. 

Proof of ayurvedic dangers is plentiful:
This is illustrated by the case of Rauwolfia serpentina, one of the few Indian medicinal herbs to find its way into Western medicine. Beginning in the 1950s, the main active component of the herb, reserpine, was used to treat psychosis and high blood pressure. Careful studies since then have shown that the drug can cause depression, headaches, nightmares, irregular heartbeat, diminished libido, aggravation of ulcers, and a variety of other adverse effects. At the same time, safer and more effective drugs were developed for treating psychosis and hypertension. The turnaround took place over a decade or two. Ayurvedic physicians, on the other hand, have used the herb for hundreds of years without a thorough understanding of its dangers and limitations. Because they don’t evaluate the effects of their prescriptions in a systematic, scientific manner, the same is probably true for most of the herbs they use
(See Kurt Butler, A Consumer’s Guide to “Alternative Medicine” [1992], pg. 111). 

Since Ayurveda attributes many diseases to demons and astrological influences, it is not surprising that incantations, amulets, spells, and mantras are commonly used remedies. Goat feces washed with urine is prescribed for alcoholism and indigestion, milk mixed with urine for constipation. Enemas of animal blood are recommended for hemorrhage. Enemas of urine and peacock testicles are used to treat impotence. Hundreds of such remedies are codified in ayurvedic texts such as Caraka Samhita, translated and edited by P. V. Sharma. (Ibid, pg.112; Emphasis mine). 

How can Dr. Chopra, a Board Certified endocrinologist in the United States, take this pseudo-medicinal and dangerous practice seriously? It is because his pagan-New Age ideology has led him to believe that people can stop aging and disease--possibly even cheating death itself. That's what makes him so popular among the masses. 

Chopra in His Own Words
The ancient doctors of India were also great sages, and their cardinal belief was that the body is created out of consciousness…. Theirs was a medicine of consciousness, and their way of treating disease pierced the body’s matter and went deeper, into the core of mind. When you look at ayurveda’s anatomical charts, you don’t see the familiar organs pictured in Gray’s Anatomy, but a hidden diagram of where the mind is flowing as it creates the body. This flow is what ayurveda treats.(See Quantum Healing pgs. 5-6). 

Hence, ayurveda is thus not based on the scientific disciplines or on traditional anatomy but upon the theory that the physical body is part of the “flow” of the mind. 

In ayurveda, each and every symptom of disease, from a minor neck pain to a full-blown cancer, is under the control of attention [divine consciousness]. However, between us and the symptom lie barriers—the veils called Maya [Hindu for illusion]—that prevent us from exercising our attention [divine consciousness] in a therapeutic way. All mind-body medicine attempts to remove these obstacles so that healing can take place….[It is important] to have a science of awareness. Ayurveda supplies just that…. When I teach people Maharishi’s ayurvedic healing techniques…. I am trying to let them realize that their own awareness [divine consciousness] creates, controls, and turns into their bodies…. Together, meditation, the bliss technique, and primordial sound are the practical application of all that I have been building up to, the tools of quantum healing. (Ibid, pgs. 237-239).

The pantheistic-Hindu concept of the world being "part of the Divine" is clearly shown. In his 1994 book Ageless Body, Timeless Mind: The Quantum Alternative to Growing Old, Chopra informs his readers who desire “true health” that they must discard ten false and harmful assumptions con­cerning who they are and the world in which they live. These “dangerous” assump­tions include such ideas as:

There is an objective world independent of the observer, and our bodies are an aspect of this objective world…. Materialism is primary, consciousness is secondary…. Our perception of the world is automatic and gives us an accurate picture of how things really are…. [We are inevitable victims of sickness, aging, and death.] (See Ageless Body, Timeless Mind: The Quantum Alternative to Growing Old pgs.4-7)

Chopra proceeds to argue that such false ideas are part of the passing “old paradigm” and are inaccurate reflections of true reality. In fact, he offers the incred­ible explanation that such ideas “are inventions of the human mind….”! Suppos­edly, the only reason that we accept anything as objectively or phenomenologically real is because of the “tyranny of the senses.” Even time and space are them­selves mere “products of our five senses.” (Ibid) He claims we have a "quantum mechanical body" and if we make our reality ageless and disease-free, we can be cured of every ailment, stay healthy and remain forever young. It is ludicrous for a trained medical doctor and former chief of staff at a major hospital to even assume there is such a thing as a “quantum mechanical body,” let alone to base an entire system of healthcare upon it; further, to tell people that aging and disease can be prevented by adopting occult beliefs and practices is pure quackery.

Chopra asserts his views are clearly supported by quantum physics and for years he refers readers to the book The Cosmic Code: Quantum Physics as the Language of Nature by eminent physicist Heinz R. Pagels. Ironically, Pagels himself denounces Chopra’s claims as “nonsense.”  (See Andrew A. Skolnick, “Maharishi Ayur-Veda: Guru’s Marketing Scheme Promises the World Eternal ‘Perfect Health,’” Journal of the American Medical Association, October 1991, p. 1749).

Chopra's False "Christ"
How are those who allegedly profess Christianity taken in by Chopra? They buy his books and live by his advice seeing no conflict between his teachings and Christ. A true deceiver, Chopra wrote two books on Our Lord Jesus Christ; Jesus: A Story of Enlightenment (2008), and The Third Jesus: The Christ We Cannot Ignore (2009). The Indian doctor informs us Christ is God in the same pantheistic sense we are all "God." He claims, like the Buddha, Christ was especially "enlightened." How did He become so? Between the age of 12 when He was found in the Temple by His Blessed Mother and St. Joseph, and before His public ministry at age 30, Christ traveled to India and "became wise from their (occult)  teachings" (just as Chopra did in 1981). 

He bases this claim on the Gnostic so-called "gospels" which were universally rejected by the early Church as false. In the Gnostic "Gospel of St Thomas," Jesus is falsely said to have stated, "I am the light that is over all things. I am all: from me all came forth, and to me all attained. Split a piece of wood; I am there. Lift up the stone, and you will find me there." (See Jesus: A Story of Enlightenment, pg. 77). This is used to promote his pantheism blasphemously using Jesus as "proof." The assertion that Jesus went to India is actually based on a book written in 1894 by Nicholas Notovitch entitled The Life of Saint Issa, in which he claims to have seen an ancient document in a Himalayan monastery that describes Christ studying Buddhism in India. When journalists went there, not only was there no evidence of any such document, it was proven Notovich was never there. It was all a hoax that made him money.  

Proselytizing Followers of Chopra
Since Deepak Chopra combines Hinduism and New Age ideologies (along with pseudo-medicine) the best way to reach his followers is by attacking aspects of those beliefs. 

  • Chopra asserts that people who believe in a world external to their senses are caught in the grip of an illusion, because "all is one." How does Chopra know it is we who are deceived by our common sense experience and not himself for thinking that "all is one;" contrary to what reason and sense experience tells us?
  • The burden of proof is clearly on Chopra to tell us why we should abandon our common ability to distinguish between fact and fantasy. We should believe what our experience tells us is true unless or until we have good reason to think otherwise. Chopra reverses this and would have us believe what is counter-intuitive is true despite the lack of evidence. This is absurd.
  • How can you believe a man who claims his theories of medicine are based on quantum physics, yet no physicist, including the one he cites, has ever supported him but actually dismissed his claims as nonsense?
  • He makes claims about Jesus Christ (such as traveling to India) which are demonstrable lies. His information also comes from Gnostic texts, which were long ago proven false.
  • If we create reality, who created us? Do other minds exist, or are other people just "reality we create"? Chopra replaces God with YOU. Do you really think you are "god"? 
      Conclusion
      People who desire “true health” will discover their best odds can be found through a healthy lifestyle and a responsible application of scientifically sound medi­cine, not in ancient occult paganism rooted in pantheistic concepts. Christ is God Incarnate, not an enlightened "god among many" Who studied Buddhism in India. It is to such paganism that Chopra and ayurveda would have us devote our souls. In a sane world, he would be stripped of his licenses to practice medicine. Worse than his damage to bodies, is his leading of souls to eternal death.

      If it were ever made a cause of action, Chopra should be sued for "theological malpractice." 

      Monday, February 22, 2021

      The Genderbread Person

       

      The latest battle for the heart and soul of Christian Civilization (whatever is left of it) consists in a battle for the minds of the young. Abraham Lincoln is credited with having said, "The philosophy of the school room in one generation will be the philosophy of government in the next." Not just the government, but the faith and morals of humanity will be definitively shaped by what is taught to the children. Satan wants a generation of perverts because they serve him well. Think of the sodomites planted by the Communists in the seminaries. They continue to reap the evil fruits of the bad seeds sown.

      Do you know the Genderbread Person? If not, you need to—and especially if you have children. The Genderbread Person ("GP") is the centerpiece of an entire curriculum for students starting in elementary school (as young as first grade), explaining how to identify the "LGBTQ identities." In a lesson plan entitled Genderbread Person and LGBTQ Umbrella (See thesafezoneproject.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/GenderbreadPersonLGBTQUmbrella.pdf) here is what children will be taught:

      LGB all represent sexual identities. And the T represents a gender identity, as well as an umbrella term for many gender identities. Queer means different things to different people, for some it describes sexuality, for others their gender, for others both. When we say “sexual identities or sexual orientations” what we are talking about are the ways we categorize and define who we are attracted to, romantically, sexually, or otherwise. When we say “gender identities” we are talking about the ways we categorize and define our genders….

      Gender is best understood when broken up into three parts: gender identity (which is how you, in your head, define and understand your gender based on the options for gender you know to exist), gender expression (the ways you demonstrate gender through your dress, actions, and demeanor), and biological sex (the physical parts of your body that we think of as either male or female). Let’s talk about these one-by-one. 

      Gender is now taught as three different parts of a human as the GP (shown at the top of this post) is designed to show as a visual aid. The consequences of this teaching are staggering. Reality is independent of what I’m aware of in my head, yet the GP curriculum is teaching children the exact opposite. According to this perverse curriculum, objective reality can change depending on what is available "in your head." The whole raison d'etre of the GP is to remove gender from the realm of objective reality to subjective preference or experience. Likewise, Modernism also removes God and the things of God from objective reality to subjective experience.

       As a result of this brainwashing, there are more and more confused children who want to be "identified as transsexual" and "transition" (figuratively and often surgically) to the opposite sex. 

      How did we get to such a sorry state? In this post I will explore Gender Theory, its origin, its consequences, and how to shield yourself and your children from this evil. 

      WARNING! This post contains some discussion of abuse and sensitive matters that some may find disturbing. Reader discretion is advised---Introibo

      What is "Gender Theory"?
      As seen above, it is the false and unscientific idea that each person is made up of different aspects of each gender. It is broken down as follows:
      • Sex has to do with the body/biology (genitals, chromosomes, etc.)
      • Gender Identity concerns the "self-awareness" of who you are "in your head"
      • Gender Expression is how someone presents themselves to others in terms of clothes, actions, mannerisms, etc.
      • Attraction is who or what someone is attracted to sexually; men, women, even animals (beastiality)
      Allegedly, everyone has a gender identity which may or may not conform with their biological sex. 

      The Four Falsehoods of Gender Theory
      1. Binary is bad.
      The claim: There are more than two genders. 

      The truth: God created male and female--period. It is the very basis of the sodomites' "LGBT" label. Lesbians are women attracted to other women. "Gays" are men attracted to other men. Bisexuals are men or women attracted to both men and women. Transgenders are men or women who want to live as the opposite sex. 

      2. Gender is a spectrum.
      The claim: There are many different genders on a whole spectrum of identity.

      The truth: There are many different ways we express masculinity and femininity because we are all different people. That doesn't imply there are roughly seven billion different genders. The reality remains that we are male or female. According to ABC News, there are 58 genders (See eroscoaching.com/2017/06/58-gender-options/). Does anyone even know what "Two-Spirit" means and how it differs from being "Genderqueer" or "Neutrois"? Sheer insanity.

      3. Man and Woman are merely "social constructs"
      The claim: The social roles of men and women differ according to time, place, and culture. There is nothing objective about those terms.

      The truth: Social roles may change, but sexual differentiation is based on biological facts, not social constructs.

      4. Gender identity is separate from biological sex.
      The claim: How we live our lives is independent from our genitalia.

      The truth: A comprehensive survey of the scientific evidence was published in 2016 in The New Atlantis. It discussed over 200 peer-reviewed studies in the biological, psychological, and social sciences. It concluded: 

      The hypothesis that gender identity is an innate, fixed property of human beings that is independent of biological sex--that a person might be "a man trapped in a woman's body," or a "woman trapped in a man's body"---is not supported by scientific evidence. (See Meyer and McHugh, "Sexuality and Gender: Findings from the Biological, Psychological, and Social Sciences," The New Atlantic: A Journal of Technology & Society, 50, Fall 2016, pg. 8; Emphasis mine).

      The Invented Vocabulary of a Warped Ideology
      The following words and phrases are made up by gender theorists to make them sound as if what they are peddling is real instead of jabberwocky. 

      Assigned at Birth: This made up phrase refers to the sex given on a person's birth certificate. It's as if some nurse puts a label in an arbitrary and capricious manner on a baby. The obvious attempt is to, once more, dissociate biological sex from gender. To label a child with male genitalia as a boy and female genitalia as a girl is biologically factual regardless of what that child may "feel like" in the future. Only in rare instances of a child born with a true intersex condition, having genitals of an ambiguous nature, would the term really apply.

      Cisgender: "Cis" means "on the same side" implying that your gender lines up with your biological sex and plays into the lie that they can be separated. If anyone asks me if I'm cisgender, I always reply, "No, I'm a man." 

      Preferred Gender Pronouns (PGPs) and Gender Neutral Pronouns (GNPs): This allows men who consider themselves women to call themselves "she" and "her" while women who think they are men can call themselves "he" and "his." Gender neutral pronouns such as "they" and "them"  are also used. About a year ago, I was reading an article in the New York Times. A trans-pervert was stopped from going somewhere and it read, "They were refused entry." As someone who reads English it was confusing because I thought several people were prevented from going some place when it was just one person. There are also made up pronouns like ze (pronounced "ZEE") and hir (pronounced "HEAR.").

      Transphobic: A fictitious mental disorder by which people who don't believe there are 58 genders and you can "pick your pronouns" are thereby psychologically unsound, hateful, and bigoted. It is a way to bully Christians and those with traditional values not to speak out or else they will face consequences.  

      Some Inherent Contradictions in Gender Theory: 
      • Gender Theorists want gender dysphoria not regarded as a mental illness, but as something to be celebrated. This includes "transition surgery" at a time when insurance and health professionals should concentrate on cancer, heart disease, COVID, and never on unnecessary surgery to further the cause of mental and/or moral problems
      • Gender Theorists insist that "gender is fluid," yet once you have surgery the damage is done permanently--there is no "going back." How is this "fluid"?
      • The idea of "gender fluidity" being natural, goes contrary to surgical intervention. It doesn't "just happen naturally" as is claimed
      Gender Theory's Origin: Perversion and Marxism
      There are ten (10) individuals who made Gender Theory a force in modern society. I want to cite E.S. Williams, Lessons in Depravity, [2003],for much of the information in this section. 

      1. Karl Ulrichs (1825-1895)
      A nineteenth century German jurist and sodomite who campaigned for "homosexual rights." He advanced an esoteric and occult idea that homosexuality was innate because there was a female soul trapped in a man's body and vice-versa for lesbians. The term “Uranian” had been coined in the 1860s by the German Karl Heinrich Ulrichs, who used “Uranian” (frequently Germanised as Urning) to signify those who experienced “a congenital reversal of sexual feeling”. “Uranian” was also a term much used in astrological and esoteric circles – usually in reference to the planet Uranus, which was associated with “awakening the soul from lethargy, and bringing it into strange conditions and hazardous enterprises”. Esoterically, at the time, the influence of Uranus was very much bound up with the idea that human culture was entering a New Age.(See http://enfolding.org/occult-gender-regimes-reincarnation-and-uranian-souls-in-the-nineteenth-century/; Emphasis mine). 

      2. Sigmund Freud (1856-1939)
      The so-called "Father of Psychoanalysis," was an Austrian atheist who denied children had a latency period but were sexual from birth. God was a projection for the need of a father-figure, and shame regarding sex acts of any persuasion were not healthy. Freud's Projection Theory commits the genetic fallacy in logic. This occurs when you try to discredit an idea based on its origin. Even if belief in God came from an unconscious desire for a father-figure, this doesn't prove God non-existent. Perhaps the very reason we have such a desire is because Our Creator made it innate within us to seek Him out. But was Freud a man who "had it all together" and was a convinced atheist? Dr. Paul Vitz, a former professor of psychology at New York University, and a former atheist himself, gives us some insight into Freud in his book Sigmund Freud's Christian Unconscious. [1988]

      Here are some interesting facts on the "Father of Psychotherapy:"
      • Freud was very interested in occult phenomena such as telepathy and poltergeists
      • On Saturday evenings, he would frequently play tarock - a form of a tarot card game associated with the Jewish Kabbala
      • In 1937, when he was urged to flee Nazism, he responded that his real enemy was the Roman Catholic Church
      • Was a cocaine addict and his excuse was  "I was making frequent use of cocaine to reduce some troublesome nasal swellings." 
      • The Catholic psychiatrist Gregory Zilboorg concluded: "Religion was, for Freud, a field of which he knew very little and which moreover seems to have been the very center of his inner conflicts, conflicts that were never resolved."
      (See also The Freudian Fallacy: Freud and Cocaine by E M Thornton [1986]).

      3. Magnus Hirschfeld (1894-1956)
      Hirschfeld was a sodomite doctor and activist. He founded the Institute for Sexual Science at Berlin in 1919. He oversaw the first "sex reassignment surgeries." The most famous was that of Einar Wegener portrayed in the 2015 movie The Danish Girl. Hirschfeld believed all people were a mixture of male and female. In 1930, he gave the first scientific lecture on "transsexualism."

      4. Alfred Kinsey (1894-1956)
      Alfred Charles Kinsey, was raised the son of a strict Methodist Sunday School teacher. He went to Bowdoin College where he majored in zoology, and developed a fascination with insects. He continued his studies at Harvard after graduation. He eventually severed all ties with his parents, and declared himself an atheist. Some of his biographers portray him as shy and disinterested in sex, but later biographers unearthed Kinsey's personal correspondence, wherein it was revealed he was a bisexual with a strong sexual desire for young boys.

      His career as a "sexpert" began when the Association of Women Students at Indiana University (where he taught zoology/biology) asked him to teach a marriage course on human sexuality for engaged and married students. Kinsey went to great lengths to keep his personal dark predilections a secret. When Ralph Voris, one of his best friends, died, Kinsey drove from Indiana to Ohio with his wife Clara. He had a wife and kids as a "cover" for his deviance. Once in Ohio, he removed correspondence from Voris' office in which Kinsey brags to Voris about his collection of "gorgeous" photos of homosexual men. 

        Kinsey revolutionized the world with the publication of his books Sexual Behavior in the Human Male and Sexual Behavior in the Human Female (published in 1948 and 1953, respectively). It was based on 350 questions on a questionnaire that asked such things as when (not if ) the interviewees had participated in sado-masochism, homosexual acts, pedophilia, and bestiality. His assistants, Clyde Martin, Paul Gebhard, and Wardell Pomeroy, were all required to be filmed performing sex acts with others either at the university or in the attic of the Kinsey home. The questions were so sick, that most of the respondents were either those who engaged in unnatural sex acts or were incarcerated sex offenders. The peer-reviewed medical journal The Lancet decried the research as having "questioned an unrepresentative proportion of prison inmates and sex offenders in a survey of normal sexual behavior." In a 1992 telephone interview, Paul Gebhard, one of Kinsey's assistants, admitted that some of the men interviewed were convicted pedophiles.

       As a result of his pseudo-scientific research, the American public began to see homosexuality and pornography as normal. Kinsey believed no sex act was unnatural, nothing was off-limits, and you could define your sexuality any way you wanted. He even approved of beastiality.

      5. Harry Benjamin (1885-1986)
      Benjamin was an associate of Kinsey. In 1966, he wrote the first textbook on transsexualism. In the book, he argued that Darwinian evolution proved gender fluidity, and pioneered the idea that if someone thought they were the wrong sex, the body should be made to align to the thoughts rather than helping them mentally so their mind would conform to objective biological reality. Benjamin (like Kinsey) endorsed a book by their friend Rene Guyon, The Ethics of Sexual Acts, [1948], which advocated pedophilia and its decriminalization. 

      6. Wilhelm Reich (1897-1957)
      An Austrian medical doctor and psychoanalyst, Reich taught that suffering and cruelty in society are due to Christian morality. In his 1933 book, The Mass Psychology of Fascism, he argued that fascism arose from sexual oppression. He was pressured to leave Catholic Austria and came to the United States where he promoted sex education for children, so they could become sexually active and "liberated." In the 1940s he promoted divorce, contraception, abortion, and promiscuity. He eventually settled in Arizona where he came to believe that the planet was under attack by UFOs and his father was an extraterrestrial. 

      7. John Money (1921-2006)
      A psychiatry professor, Money campaigned to legalize pedophilia and the "freedom to change gender." He co-founded the Johns Hopkins Gender Identity Clinic. His most famous case involved David Reimer, whose circumcision had gone wrong. Money pressured the boy's parents to agree to an experimental surgery in order to "change the little boy into a girl." Money wanted to prove gender is all about socialization and not biology. Since David had a twin brother named Brian, if David (now called Brenda) could be successfully raised as a girl, while twin brother Brian would be a boy, his theory would be vindicated. 

      It would be later revealed that Money forced the two children to engage in incestuous acts with each other while he photographed them. When David found out the truth about being a boy, he wanted to transition back. Not being able to do so, he tragically committed suicide at age 38. As a result of the abuse, Brian became a drug addict and died from an overdose at age 36. (See David van Gend, Stealing from a Child: The Injustice of "Marriage Equality."[2016], pgs. 152-153). 

      8. Robert Stoller (1924-1991)
      A Professor of  Psychiatry at UCLA, Stoller presented his ideas that gender and biological sex are distinct and separate in his influential book Sex and Gender (1968). He denied that there was any distinction between normal and perverted sex; the only thing that is wrong is to infringe on the rights of other people. 

      9. Antonio Gramsci (1891-1937)
      An Italian Marxist, Gramsci believed in the complete overthrow of Christian morals in society. Complete license to act as you wish (especially in sexual matters) was of paramount importance, and must only be curtailed when absolutely necessary by the State. You achieve this by distancing youself from the label of Marxism, and use the language of "equality" and "freedom."

      10. Herbert Marcuse (1898-1979)
      Marcuse was a Marxist philosopher and sociologist. His lasting and destructive legacy was destroying any confidence in objective truth. He achieved this by claiming words don't actually mean anything; they are just tools to achieve what the writer or speaker wants. It is often called "critical theory" and has had great success. (For more on this topic, please see last week's post by A Simple Man [my guest-poster] entitled "What's In A Word?"---Introibo).

      The evil influence of these characters, exacerbated by the Great Apostasy of Vatican II, has brought society to a place where one can say with a straight face, "A man can be a woman and a woman can be a man."

      The Evil Consequences of Gender Theory
      The Yogyakarta Principles, were written by a group of self-anointed "human rights experts" in Yogyakarta, Indonesia. (See http://yogyakartaprinciples.org/principles-en/yp10/). They urge that governments must accept Gender Theory, and must consider as "unlawful discrimination" any attempt to oppose it. If successful, the following ideas, if expressed, could come with legal sanctions:
      • Marriage is only between a biological man and biological woman
      • Sexual activity is restricted to married couples
      • Children have a right to know their parents and be brought up by one father and one mother
      • Human beings are male and female from birth
      Other consequences:
      • In NYC, a person who intentionally and repeatedly refuses to use an individual’s preferred pronoun would be subject to fines (that could reach as high as $250,000 for multiple violations) under the law passed in 2015. (See nypost.com/2016/05/19/city-issues-new-guidelines-on-transgender-pronouns).
      • A male rapist in the UK identified as a woman and was allowed to go to the prison for women, even though biologically male. The result? "Karen White" sexually assaulted a real female prisoner. (See theguardian.com/uk-news/2018/oct/11/transgender-prisoner-who-sexually-assaulted-inmates-jailed-for-life). 
      • The current occupant of the White House wants transgenders to compete on sports teams of the gender with which they identify. This means smaller, lighter, and less strong girls will compete against boys pretending to be girls.
      • Wellesley College has adopted this admission policy:
      Wellesley will consider for admission any applicant who lives as a woman and consistently identifies as a woman. Therefore, candidates assigned male at birth who identify as women are eligible to apply for admission. The College also accepts applications from those who were assigned female at birth, identify as non-binary, and who feel they belong in our community of women. Those assigned female at birth who identify as men are not eligible for consideration for admission.  (See https://www.wellesley.edu/news/gender-policy). So if you're a man who thinks you're a woman you can go to a college for women. If you're a woman who thinks she's a man, you cannot be admitted. 
      • We are enabling the mentally ill who are suffering gender dysphoria and who need psychological help. They should not be told to "celebrate who they really are." Just as anorexics are treated so they don't see their emaciated bodies as "obese," (and we do not tell them their perception is correct), we must do the same for those who suffer gender dysphoria. Gender dysphoria used to be called gender identity disorder, but was renamed under political pressure from sodomite groups who objected to the term "disorder." They want it removed from the DSM (book of mental health issues) altogether unless it is defined in such a way as to make those who have the condition automatic candidates for surgical reassignment to the opposite sex. 
      The Assault on God
      Two Vatican II sect "theologians" have come out in favor of Gender Theory. Will they be censured or excommunicated? (Rhetorical question). 

      Michael G. Lawler and Todd A. Salzman, both LGBTQ-positive theologians at Creighton University, Nebraska, argue against Catholic documents such as 2019’s “Male and Female He Created Them,” from the Vatican’s Congregation for Catholic Education, and 2020’s “Compassion and Challenge,” from the Archdiocese of St. Louis, Missouri. These documents fundamentally misunderstand transgender and intersex experiences. Because of this misunderstanding, the conclusions drawn by the church amount to further discrimination against an already targeted group....The theologians assert that reliance on the Genesis account of a male-female binary consistently conflates biological sex with socially-constructed gender and diminishes the mysterious power of God, limiting God to creating only male or female. By diminishing the incomprehensible creative power of God, these documents diminish the humanity and dignity of God’s own creation. (See https://www.newwaysministry.org/2020/12/05/theologians-call-on-church-to-abandon-resistance-to-transgender-intersex-people/)

      These theologians are teaching the old heresy of Gnosticism. Gender Theory downplays the body and exalts subjective feelings. This false distinction between mind and body led those Gnostics of old to claim Christ only rose spiritually, not physically, from the dead. As Bergoglio is a religious relativist, I wouldn't be shocked if it seeps into relativism everywhere else. I could see him entertaining the idea of a woman who thinks she's a man ("trans-man") as eligible for ordination. No wonder John Paul the Great Apostate sounds profound with his inane "Theology of the Body;" "The body of a man is made for the body of a woman." What used to be common sense is now praised by Vatican II sect "conservatives" as "deep analysis." 

      Protecting the Children
      If you have children, you must protect them at all costs. If you are not near a Traditionalist school, and they must attend public school, here are some suggestions.

      1. Teach them about the Faith. 
      Children are too young to learn about perversion, but never too young to learn the truths of Holy Mother Church. Let them understand God created male and female--period. Anything else taught is evil.

      2. Don't let them be bullied in the name of "anti-bullying."
      They should never be told by school officials (teachers, principals, etc) that they must agree with the beliefs or actions of others. Disagreement is not hatred, bullying, or a mental disorder (e.g. "transphobic"). Bullying is wrong, but it also means your child's religious and ethical beliefs must be respected--otherwise it's discrimination against Traditionalists. 

      3. Do not allow stereotypes to influence them.
      Just because a girl is a "tomboy," or a boy is shy and sensitive, is no indicator that they are sodomites or "trans." Don't allow anyone to tell them otherwise.

      4. Demand to know the school's curriculum, and demand religious exemption if it offends faith or morals.
      You have a right to know what your child is being taught. Do not allow them to be subjected to brainwashing curriculum which has nothing to do with genuine learning.

      5. Always be aware of everything your child reads, watches, and who they have as friends.
      Many books, TV shows, and movies portray perversion in a positive light. Know your child's friends. Unless their parents are Traditionalists they may buy into Gender Theory and tell your kids it's normal.

      Conclusion
      Gender Theory is a lie that is embraced by many and is beginning to seriously shape our legal and educational systems. Even the Vatican II sect is on board by tolerating it and refusing to strongly condemn and extirpate it. It won't be long before Bergoglio fully embraces it; after all, "Who am I to judge?"

      I remember the innocent kids' song The Gingerbread Man. In the near future we may have Traditionalist kids singing:

      Run, run, run as fast as I can, don't want any coercion
      So you’ll never catch me, you evil Genderbread Person
      I ran from the sodomite and his trans-woman wife too.
      You’ll never catch me, not any of you.



      Monday, February 15, 2021

      What's In A Word?

       

      To My Readers: For the first time since January of 2020, I'm on vacation! The only week I could take was the week Lent begins. Thankfully, I'm close enough to a Traditionalist Chapel where I am, so I can enjoy activities with family and friends while keeping my religious obligations as well. This Lent, I'm working on becoming less of a hotheaded man--a lifelong struggle. I have made improvements (believe it or not) but I still have much work to do. Being abrasive and quick to anger often becomes a way of life as a NYC lawyer. Thanks to my guest poster, A Simple Man, for providing this week's post. Please pray for this most pious and intelligent young man that God may keep him strong in the One True Faith and bless him abundantly. He is helping me to keep this blog going in order to spread and strengthen the Faith in these perilous times. I will return with my own post next Monday, 2/22/21.

      On January 18th, I published a post against one Aaron Debusschere a Vatican II sect apologist, who attacked my charge of heresy against the Vatican II document Gaudiam et Spes on his blog. On February 13th, Debusschere responded with a post addressed as a "letter" of sorts to A Simple Man. In his post, he accuses me of not addressing his arguments (!) and not wanting "rational discourse." I'll let Simple Man decide if and when he wants to reply via a post here, on The Romantic Catholic (Debusschere's blog), or via private e-mail exchange. I added an Addendum to my post of 1/18/21 as it was easy enough to show that Debusschere--like every Vatican II sect apologist I've encountered---is clueless. You can read the Addendum after the Conclusion section here:

      introiboadaltaredei2.blogspot.com/2021/01/romanticizing-heresy.html. 

      At the top of the post remains the link to Dubusschere's blog. I think you might enjoy it, along with the fine post below by A Simple Man.

      God Bless you all, my dear readers---Introibo

      What's In A Word?
      By A Simple Man

      What is a female, at least as far as humans go? It’s a seemingly simple question. Insofar as we are considering the most general case, dictionaries from decades past would provide rather straightforward answers:

      “Among animals, one of that sex which conceives and brings forth young.” – An American Dictionary of the English Language, Noah Webster, online version of the original 1828 edition

      “fē′māl, adj. of the sex that produces young: pertaining to females: […] —n. one of the female sex, a woman.” -  Chambers’s Twentieth Century Dictionary of the English Language (Part 2 of 4: E-M)  originally published in 1908, online version hosted by Project Gutenberg

      However, if you were to turn to Merriam-Webster’s online dictionary in its most current form [as of December 8, 2020], you would find the following under the definition of female (bold is emphasis mine): “of, relating to, or being the sex that typically has the capacity to bear young or produce eggs; having a gender identity that is the opposite of male.” These terms introduce ambiguity.

      In like manner, Webster’s 1828 dictionary and Chambers’s 1908 dictionary define males as the sex with the capacity to procreate or beget young. The modern Merriam-Webster dictionary’s definition for male likewise reads like a gender-swapped version of the definition for female, including “having a gender identity that is the opposite of female.” Needless to say, this has placed circular reasoning within the two definitions themselves, so as to render the concepts of male and female nonsensical; using these modern definitions makes equivocation and homunculus arguments (the latter being an informal fallacy where a concept is explained in terms of the concept itself, without first explaining the original concept) impossible to avoid.

      Some might argue that that’s the point; after all, if you cannot agree on basic definitions, then how can anyone make proper arguments, or reason rightly?

      Why is language important? Although it would be erroneous to say that thought is impossible without language (as one medical study from 2016 regarding people with global aphasia has shown), it cannot be reasonably denied that language is the principal means by which humans communicate with each other. As languages have changed and evolved throughout the centuries, new words have been invented to designate new things (i.e. computer, telephone, rocket, etc.), while others have fallen into general disuse or restriction to specialized fields, sometimes to the point of becoming obsolete (when’s the last time you heard the words accable, conspurcation, pickeer, or regest?). However, even as languages change, and certain words may shift in spelling or form, the essence of the things that those words refer to does not change in the process. This is especially important with fundamental aspects of reality and human nature, since a poor or erroneous understanding of fundamentals will result in a skewed understanding of reality.

      Although there are philosophical variations with regards to how definitions are considered or interpreted (as the Winter 2019 edition of “Definitions” from the online Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy demonstrates), our focus will be descriptive definitions, which not only aim to communicate the meaning of a particular thing (whether it be an object, a concept, an idea, and so on), but also aim to be sufficient in that meaning. In other words, a descriptive definition is one that should provide an adequate understanding of what the object being defined, in fact, is. [ASM’s note: to be even more specific, we are looking at descriptive definitions in a “real” sense, aiming to describe the essence of the thing in question. This is in contrast to a “nominal” sense, wherein the definition seeks to describe the ideas we have about the thing in question, even if those ideas are entirely separate – or even contrary – to the real essence of the thing itself.]

      How are we able to provide definitions at all? Per St. Thomas Aquinas, our ability to understand corporeal things is due to the intellectual power of the soul. In particular, regarding to how we acquire intellectual knowledge, he says: “I answer that…Aristotle chose a middle course. For with Plato he agreed that intellect and sense are different. But he held that the sense has not its proper operation without the cooperation of the body; so that to feel is not an act of the soul alone, but of the "composite." And he held the same in regard to all the operations of the sensitive part. Since, therefore, it is not unreasonable that the sensible objects which are outside the soul should produce some effect in the "composite," Aristotle agreed with Democritus in this, that the operations of the sensitive part are caused by the impression of the sensible on the sense: not by a discharge, as Democritus said, but by some kind of operation. For Democritus maintained that every operation is by way of a discharge of atoms, as we gather from De Gener. i, 8. But Aristotle held that the intellect has an operation which is independent of the body's cooperation. Now nothing corporeal can make an impression on the incorporeal. And therefore in order to cause the intellectual operation according to Aristotle, the impression caused by the sensible does not suffice, but something more noble is required, for "the agent is more noble than the patient," as he says (De Gener. i, 5). Not, indeed, in the sense that the intellectual operation is effected in us by the mere impression of some superior beings, as Plato held; but that the higher and more noble agent which he calls the active intellect, of which we have spoken above (I:79:4) causes the phantasms [ASM’s note: a phantasm, as St. Thomas uses it philosophically, is the likeness of a particular thing, or the means by which representations of real things are perceived and understood by the intellect; see ST I, q. 84, a. 7, ad 2 & ad 3 for more.] received from the senses to be actually intelligible, by a process of abstraction. According to this opinion, then, on the part of the phantasms, intellectual knowledge is caused by the senses. But since the phantasms cannot of themselves affect the passive intellect, and require to be made actually intelligible by the active intellect, it cannot be said that sensible knowledge is the total and perfect cause of intellectual knowledge, but rather that it is in a way the material cause.” – ST I, q. 84, a. 6

      In other words, it is through the senses of the body that our intellect perceives concrete things; from these perceptions, our intellect is capable of abstraction, by which we can understand the object as it is. (Such a process is not to be confused with subjective experience in the sense often used in modern times, which asserts that our encounters with things cannot provide any objective information about them. Objective information is necessarily true regardless of who subjectively experiences it.) Thus are we capable of attaining knowledge; furthermore, it is through this process of apprehension and abstraction that we are able to generalize, and understand things which are universal or immaterial. (Questions 84 through 89 of the First Part of the Summa Theologiae consider the acts of the intellect and how we are capable of understanding. However, the chosen excerpt suffices for the topic at hand.)

      Per the 1910 Catholic Encyclopedia, the essentials of knowledge are as follows: “Knowledge is essentially the consciousness of an object, i.e. of any thing, fact, or principle belonging to the physical, mental, or metaphysical order, that may in any manner be reached by cognitive faculties. An event, a material substance, a man, a geometrical theorem, a mental process, the immortality of the soul, the existence and nature of God, may be so many objects of knowledge...Knowledge supposes a judgment, explicit or implicit. Apprehension, that is, the mental conception of a simple present object, is generally numbered among the cognitive processes, yet, of itself, it is not in the strict sense knowledge, but only its starting-point. Properly speaking, we know only when we compare, identify, discriminate, connect; and these processes, equivalent to judgments, are found implicitly even in ordinary sense-perception...Truth and certitude are conditions of knowledge. A man may mistake error for truth and give his unreserved assent to a false statement. He may then be under the irresistible illusion that he knows, and subjectively the process is the same as that of knowledge; but an essential condition is lacking, namely, conformity of thought with reality, so that there we have only the appearance of knowledge. On the other hand, as long as any serious doubt remains in his mind, a man cannot say that he knows. "I think so" is far from meaning "I know it is so"; knowledge is not mere opinion or probable assent...”

      To summarize, we are able to provide descriptive definitions of things because our intellect is capable of apprehending these things as they are. To deny this capacity of the intellect is to implicitly abolish the very possibility of objective truth, for we would be unable to truly differentiate between things in themselves, and thus unable to differentiate between truth and falsehood.

      What are the consequences of abandoning this approach to knowledge? To deny the possibility of descriptive definitions requires an epistemological and metaphysical worldview that is incompatible with Catholicism, and Thomism in particular. As has been seen from various figures in past centuries, their attempts to abandon the realism of Scholastic philosophy has resulted in numerous, often contradictory theories of knowledge. In particular, René Descartes’s decision to start from a position of absolute doubt has ushered forth entire schools which reject or distort the traditional concept of metaphysics altogether; without Descartes’s starting point, we may never have arrived at the notorious ideas of individuals like John Locke (who, as an empiricist, aimed at dethroning Aristotelianism and Scholasticism from the universities), Immanuel Kant (who professed that he “had to deny knowledge in order to make room for faith”, restricting knowledge to an empirical realm such that God and the soul were unknowable by the human mind; furthermore, he insisted that we are incapable of experiencing things in themselves), and Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel (whose ideas have been acknowledged as the precursor to existentialism [ASM’s note: Introibo recently wrote about some of the errors of existentialist philosophy in “Encountering Error”], phenomenology, and the philosophies of more notorious individuals like Karl Marx and Friedrich Nietzsche).* Thus have we meandered our way to the modern world, where mainstream philosophy and epistemology have become so deranged that objective truth is rejected altogether: “If there were objective values, then they would be entities or qualities or relations of a very strange sort, utterly different from anything else in the universe.” – Mackie, John Leslie. Ethics: inventing right and wrong. London, Penguin Books, 1977, p. 38 [ASM’s note: J.L. Mackie (1917 – 1981) was an Australian philosopher known for being a moral skeptic and a staunch atheist; the aforementioned book infamously opens with the claim that “there are no objective values.”]

      Such is the scourge of the philosophies employed by Modernism, which has been covered before on this blog. Papal condemnations of Modernists and their ideas are many:

      “[…]Let us turn for a moment, Venerable Brethren, to that most disastrous doctrine of agnosticism. By it every avenue to God on the side of the intellect is barred to man, while a better way is supposed to be opened from the side of a certain sense of the soul and action. But who does not see how mistaken is such a contention? For the sense of the soul is the response to the action of the thing which the intellect or the outward senses set before it. Take away the intelligence, and man, already inclined to follow the senses, becomes their slave. Doubly mistaken, from another point of view, for all these fantasies of the religious sense will never be able to destroy common sense, and common sense tells us that emotion and everything that leads the heart captive proves a hindrance instead of a help to the discovery of truth. We speak of truth in itself — for that other purely subjective truth, the fruit of the internal sense and action, if it serves its purpose for the play of words, is of no benefit to the man who wants above all things to know whether outside himself there is a God into whose hands he is one day to fall...” -  Pope Pius X, Pascendi Dominici Gregis (On the Doctrine of the Modernists), 1907, par. 39

      “[…]There are to be found today, and in no small numbers, men, of whom the Apostle says that: "having itching ears, they will not endure sound doctrine: but according to their own desires they will heap up to themselves teachers, and will indeed turn away their hearing from the truth, but will be turned unto fables" (II Tim. iv. 34). Infatuated and carried away by a lofty idea of the human intellect, by which God’s good gift has certainly made incredible progress in the study of nature, confident in their own judgment, and contemptuous of the authority of the Church, they have reached such a degree of rashness as not to hesitate to measure by the standard of their own mind even the hidden things of God and all that God has revealed to men. Hence arose the monstrous errors of "Modernism," which Our Predecessor rightly declared to be "the synthesis of all heresies," and solemnly condemned. We hereby renew that condemnation in all its fulness, Venerable Brethren, and as the plague is not yet entirely stamped out, but lurks here and there in hidden places, We exhort all to be carefully here and there in hidden places, We exhort all to be carefully on their guard against any contagion of the evil, to which we may apply the words Job used in other circumstances: "It is a fire that devoureth even to destruction, and rooteth up all things that spring" (Job xxxi. 12). Nor do We merely desire that Catholics should shrink from the errors of Modernism, but also from the tendencies or what is called the spirit of Modernism. Those who are infected by that spirit develop a keen dislike for all that savours of antiquity and become eager searchers after novelties in everything: in the way in which they carry out religious functions, in the ruling of Catholic institutions, and even in private exercises of piety...” – Pope Benedict XV, Ad Beatissimi Apostolorum (Appealing for Peace), 1914, par. 25

      “[St. Thomas’s] teaching with regard to the power or value of the human mind is irrefragable. "The human mind has a natural knowledge of being and the things which are in themselves part of being as such, and this knowledge is the foundation of our knowledge of first principles" (Contra Gentes, II, 1xxxiii). Such a doctrine goes to the root of the errors and opinions of those modern philosophers who maintain that it is not being itself which is perceived in the act of intellection, but some modification of the percipient; the logical consequence of such errors is agnosticism, which was so vigorously condemned in the Encyclical Pascendi… if we are to avoid the errors which are the source and fountain-head of all the miseries of our time, the teaching of Aquinas must be adhered to more religiously than ever. For Thomas refutes the theories propounded by Modernists in every sphere, in philosophy, by protecting, as We have reminded you, the force and power of the human mind and by demonstrating the existence of God by the most cogent arguments…It is therefore clear why Modernists are so amply justified in fearing no Doctor of the Church so much as Thomas Aquinas.” – Pope Pius XI, Studiorum Ducem (On St. Thomas Aquinas), 1923,  par. 15, 27

      In conclusion, it is incumbent upon us in these days to stand up for objective truth, to articulate the importance of acknowledging reality as it is, and to point out the errors which spawn from ignoring such. Even in the face of those who would scream that we are simply being “intolerant” or “bigoted”, we must affirm and uphold the intrinsic value of definitions which describe things in themselves. Ambiguous and subjective terms are a recipe for logical and rhetorical disaster, as can be seen from the actions and behavior of those who can say (with a straight face!) that a human born with male genitalia and chromosomes is, in fact, a woman; that a marriage can include sodomitical, zoophilic, or even objectophilic relationships; that non-Catholics do, in fact, possess means of salvation separate from Jesus Christ and His Church; and so on.

      To behave as if such definitions (and the concepts derived from them) are arbitrary or irrelevant is to reject your God-given nature as a rational being.

       

      * For additional reading about the philosophy of Descartes and his intellectual successors compared to that of St. Thomas Aquinas, I highly recommend the essay written by the Traditionalist Mario Derksen titled “Against the Skeptics: How Thomist Realism Refutes Radical Skepticism”; it covers more details (which were glossed over in this post for the sake of brevity) regarding the origin of modern philosophical skepticism and how St. Thomas explains the workings of human knowledge.